Refine Search
Sort by
$849,900
3 Beds 2 Baths Marnita C Swickard
Experience the ultimate waterfront oasis in this masterfully reimagined retreat, where 100 feet of pristine shoreline meets the glow of endless western sunsets. Originally rebuilt with uncompromising quality by Amish craftsmen in 2020, this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home was designed with a 'no detail left out' philosophy, focusing on structural integrity and a low-maintenance exterior. The heart of the home is an expansive open-concept great room that flows seamlessly into a kitchen featuring crisp white cabinetry, sophisticated leathered granite countertops, and premium stainless steel appliances. Retreat to the primary bedroom, strategically positioned to face the water, offering breathtaking, panoramic lake views the moment you wake up. The outdoor living space is a true entertainer's dream, engineered for grand parties or intimate evening gatherings. Step out onto sprawling composite decking equipped with SunSetter awnings for custom shade and professional landscape lighting that transforms the property at twilight. For the water enthusiast, the lakefront infrastructure is second to none, featuring a new seawall and a custom-covered boat dock with a lift, expertly installed by Cottage Maintenance in 2022. Every element of this property has been curated for those who demand quality without the burden of constant upkeep. Whether you are looking for a premier summer home or a sophisticated weekend escape, this property offers the gold standard of lake living. Simply arrive, unwind, and take in the most spectacular sunset views on the water. This is more than a home; it is a meticulously crafted sanctuary built to be enjoyed for generations.

3278 South Bank Road NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Marnita C Swickard ---- e-Merge Real Estate

$599,900
3 Beds 2 Baths Marnita C Swickard
Imagine waking up to the glow of a Buckeye Lake sunrise stretching across the water with your coffee in hand, the lake calm, and the day full of possibility. That's the everyday experience this well-cared-for main lake cottage delivers! Opportunities like this are rare, homes that have been thoughtfully maintained and updated over the years. From the moment you arrive, you'll sense the pride of ownership and the simple charm that makes lake living so special. Inside, the home welcomes you with a warm, cozy cottage feel. Two bedrooms and a full hall bath are located on the street level, perfect for family or weekend guests. The heart of the home, the kitchen & great room is where lake life truly unfolds. Oak cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, & open views of the water create a space that's both functional and inviting. Just down the hall, the spacious primary suite offers its own bath and a comfortable retreat after a full day on the water. Step outside and the story continues. A covered porch for shaded afternoons. A sun deck for soaking in the rays. Your own boat dock ready for early morning fishing trips or sunset cruises. This is where memories are made, long summer days, laughter with friends, and traditions that carry on for years to come. Storage is well thought out with a one-car garage offering extra depth for lake toys and gear, plus a separate shed for tools and equipment. Across the street, additional park like land owned by the HOA is available for the owners' use, ideal for parking, boat storage, or even a garden space (no permanent structures permitted). It's a valuable bonus that adds flexibility and convenience. The location is superb. The setting is timeless. And the opportunity is limited. If you've been waiting for the right lake home, one that offers value, views, & the chance to start your own Buckeye Lake memories, this is it!

12730 West Bank Drive NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Marnita C Swickard ---- e-Merge Real Estate

$1,100,000
4 Beds 4 Baths Debbi L Popo
The most spectacular sunset views on beautiful Buckeye Lake can be yours to enjoy every night! This immaculate, open concept, almost 5000 square ft home w/ 4 attached garages is move-in ready & has brand new siding & roofing! A fabulous outdoor covered concrete patio also runs the length of the home to peruse the serenity each day in any weather. Huge great room w/ gorgeous white washed cedar walls & ceiling offers lakefront living like no other! Wall to wall windows, custom cabinets, cathedral ceilings, wood floorings, storage galore, huge pantry, and stainless appliances, are just a few of the outstanding amenities in this gorgeous home! Just park your boat(s) outside your lakeside front door & enjoy boating w/ ease from two solar powered & hoisted lifts. Four bedrooms (possible 5) & four baths! The lower level could become a wonderful in-law suite or even a rental w/ separate entrances; there is even a garage right outside it's door! Newly installed carpeting throughout the lower level, too! Walk along the biking/walking path to local restaurants & shops, or possibly the Yacht Club!

3483 North Bank Rd./Seller's Dr. NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Debbi L Popo ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

$1,850
2 Beds 1 Baths Andrew R Ankrum
Be the first to enjoy this beautifully newly built 2-bedroom, 1-bath townhouse-style apartment offering modern finishes and thoughtful design throughout. This unit features brand-new appliances, in-unit laundry, and an attached one-car garage for added convenience. Located just minutes from Buckeye Lake, you'll enjoy easy access to local restaurants, shopping, and recreation while still having a comfortable place to call home. The open layout provides a bright and welcoming living space, perfect for everyday living. Tenant responsibilities include electric, trash, lawn care, landscaping, and snow removal. No pets. No Section 8. All applicants are subject to credit and background checks.

13134 Pine Road NE, Thornville

Listing Courtesy of : Andrew R Ankrum ---- LEPI & ASSOC.

$324,900
6 Beds 6 Baths John Kohlhepp
Spacious Opportunity Near Buckeye Lake! Welcome to 11890 Broad Street in the heart of Millersport—an expansive 6-bedroom, 4.5-bath home offering incredible potential just minutes from Buckeye Lake. This large residence has had work started and is ready for a new owner to finish and customize to their vision. With its generous layout and bedroom count, this property is ideal for a vacation home, or large family retreat. Conveniently located right off the main road, you'll enjoy easy access to local restaurants, a nearby coffee shop, and all the charm Millersport has to offer—plus quick access to Buckeye Lake for boating, dining, and year-round recreation. Whether you're an investor or someone looking to create a one-of-a-kind lake-area getaway, this property presents a rare opportunity to add value in a highly desirable location.

11890 Broad Street, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : John Kohlhepp ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

$695,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Robert J Riddle
This Buckeye Lake waterfront home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, stunning views, and inviting spaces inside and out. The main floor features a bright living room with lake views, a dining area with large sliders, and a kitchen with quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, gas range, and eat-in bar. The main-level bedroom includes a walk-in closet, while the remodeled bath feels spacious with a walk in shower, wide vanity, and open shelving. Luxury vinyl flooring runs throughout. The lower level adds 2 bedrooms, a full bath, family room with fireplace, laundry, and garage with ample storage. Step outside to enjoy a back patio perfect for entertaining, a hot tub added in 2023, and direct access to a boat dock along the walking and bike path. Conveniently located near dining and shopping in Buckeye Lake Village and Millersport, and just 30 minutes from Columbus, this home offers a true lakeside lifestyle.

3371 Shepard Avenue NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Robert J Riddle ---- New Albany Realty, LTD

$213,900
2 Beds 2 Baths J. Andrew Bruck
Beautifully updated Buckeye Lake area bungalow located on a quiet street with 2 lots and just a short walk to downtown Millersport. The home features: 2 bedrooms with a newly added Jack and Jill 1/2 bath; a living room with refinished original hardwood floors; updated kitchen with a breakfast nook; a first-floor laundry; newer HVAC; attic insulation and a fully renovated bath. The front screen porch is perfect for entertaining and enjoying peaceful evenings. Outside you'll find a patio and entrance to a dry usable basement. The 2nd lot gives plenty of room to store a boat, trailer or add a future garage. Total lot size is 64x100. Some furnishings may be negotiable. Freezer to convey with the property Agent is related to seller

12291 Ohio Avenue, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : J. Andrew Bruck ---- Oreste Realty, LLC

$574,900
5 Beds 2 Baths Kathleen H Fornes
This rare rural find within a half-hour drive of downtown Columbus and New Albany boasts prime acres for homesteading and deer hunting. Perfect for kids to run wild in the woods or explore the creek. Open farm fields to the west allow unrestricted shooting. Mature apple and pear trees, grape vines, wild black raspberries, unlimited firewood, rich fertile soil. Metal chicken coop building with electric and water. 31x30 solar-powered barn. 34x24 paved garage/workshop with 220v service. The 2,380 square-foot bi-level home sits back from the road, nestled behind stately maples for added privacy. With 5 bedrooms and 2 full baths, recent renovations provide a modern feel - quartz countertops, bamboo floors, wood siding, oak woodwork, new plumbing, electric, water filtration, fixtures and trim. The woodburning stove adds ambience and lowers electricity bills in the winter. A whole house fan keeps rooms cool before turning on the AC in the summer. The private well and septic eliminate additional utility bills. Located in quiet, no-income-tax Liberty Township.

12345 Cherry Lane, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Kathleen H Fornes ---- Making Dreams Realty LLC