Refine Search
Sort by
$440,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Dana S Hess
Are you tired of Columbus or Mansfield traffic?! Would you love a property with a stunning landscape and relaxing spaces??? Come out to Mount Gilead and see this amazing homestead on more than 9 acres of property. Enjoy the beautiful fields of the butterfly sanctuary from the large composite deck or relax in the 14X30 indoor pool year round. The pool is non-chlorine and is treated with Baquacil, which is gentler on skin, hair, and bathing suits. The oversized main garage is heated and has an epoxy floor. The majestic landscape is covered in mature walnut trees, which are highly valuable if harvested. Not far from the home is a 40X40 pole barn (2022) and a separate building with electricity that could be an at-home workspace or converted into a potential ADU (water/sewer needed). Both additional structures have new metal roofs and siding. The property contains seven active springs. If the electricity goes out, no problem! The home has a Generac generator, which was installed in 2021. This home qualifies for the Homestead Reduction Tax credit. The property is approximately only 6 miles from I-71, so access to Columbus or Mansfield is very easy for commuting. Sellers are offering a $10,000 concession for updates and closing costs! Washer/dryer convey. Schedule your showing today!!

5545 County Road 240-Bryn Zion Road Road, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Dana S Hess ---- Hess Realty Group, LLC

Selling Office: Hess Realty Group, LLC.

$420,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Jeff Stuttler
Own a piece of serene countryside with this 3 bed, 2 bath ranch home, 30x40 horse barn, fenced-in pasture w/ pond access, all on 6.9 acres! Newer roof and siding ensure peace of mind for years to come. Too many updates to include! Some of the recent highlights: new carpet, kitchen counters/backsplash and a new hot water tank installed all within the last year. The attached garage was tastefully converted to extra living space, making the interior a total of 1,920 SF. Has potential to be made into a mother in law suite or rental space. Pole barn has a couple horse stalls and is equipped with electric/water. Conveniently located in Northmor school district, close to town amenities, minutes from Mount Gilead and Lexington. Don't miss out on this rare find for hobby farmers, equestrians, or anyone seeking elbow room, schedule your private tour today!

6351 US Highway 42, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Jeff Stuttler ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

$420,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Cheyenne A Peck
Welcome to this beautiful bi-level home, built in 2017, set on 2.3 acres across 2 parcels in a serene country setting surrounded by open farm fields. This property combines modern comfort with peaceful rural charm. Step inside the upper level where you'll find an inviting open-concept layout featuring a spacious living room and a stunning kitchen with new dolomite granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and warm wood flooring. The primary suite includes an extra large walk-in closet and a private en-suite bath with a custom walk in tile shower. A guest half bath is also conveniently located on this level. From the main dining area, walk out to the expansive rear balcony--perfect for enjoying the gorgeous countryside views. The walkout lower level expands your living space with a large family room and sliding doors that open to a covered concrete patio with a custom stone fireplace. Two additional spacious bedrooms, a full bath, and a generous utility room complete the lower level. The utility room offers a washer and dryer, plenty of storage, and even a handy dog shower. Additional features include a metal roof, 2 car garage, and electric heat pump with central air. This home is very energy efficient and has barely been lived in, making it almost feel like new. Enjoy the perfect balance of country living while still being just minutes from the I-71/SR 95 exit for an easy commute to Columbus. Don't miss this one of a kind property that offers space, comfort, and a gorgeous setting!

5491 Township Road 14, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Cheyenne A Peck ---- Howard Hanna - Main Office

Selling Office: KW Classic Properties Realty.

$385,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Amber L Deem
Welcome to your own private oasis! This three bed, two bathroom multi level custom built house is setting on just over an acre lot that feels like your own private park. Just inside you'll find a wide open living room and kitchen. Open views to the back and side yard. Down stairs is a bonus room to spread out and utility area. Upstairs you'll find two bedrooms, laundry room and a full bath. The third floor features the primary suite along with a balcony, a balcony over looking the back yard and a stunning bathroom with a soaking tub, stand up shower and a walk in closet. Now lets talk about the outdoor space. You've got a big 33ft pool and a hot tub for those much needed relaxing nights. Two decks, fenced in yard and nature galore. This home has all the good stuff, space privacy, and a backyard built for making memories.

5555 US Highway 42, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Amber L Deem ---- Realty Ohio Inc.

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

$385,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cheyenne A Peck
Welcome to 3581 County Road 172, Mount Gilead -- where space, comfort, and country charm come together on 5.034 beautiful acres with no close neighbors and breathtaking sunrise and sunset views! This expansive open-concept ranch home offers 2294 square feet of well designed living space, plus a full partially finished basement. The heart of the home is the stunning kitchen that flows seamlessly into the living and dining room areas--perfect for everyday living and entertaining. A separate flex space provides options for an additional sitting room, playroom, or home office. The primary suite is a relaxing retreat featuring an en-suite bath complete with large soaking tub. A 16x16 addition offers even more versatility--ideal as fourth bedroom, private office, or cozy den. You'll also love the rear covered porch/sunroom- the perfect spot to enjoy your morning coffee while watching the sunrise over your property. The finished basement adds even more living area with a spacious family room, rec room, built in bar, and abundant storage or workshop space. Outdoor living truly shines here. The 22x16 covered deck overlooks the above ground pool, creating an ideal setup for summer gatherings and entertaining. The large driveway provides ample parking for guests, trailers, or recreational vehicles. For those needed extra space for hobbies, storage, or livestock, this property delivers: -40x30 detached 2 car garage with concrete floor and electric. -32x24 barn featuring a large stall, loft, and additional farm-use space. Plenty of rural land for pastures or recreational vehicle use. Located in the Highland School District with easy interstate access and just 35 minutes North of Polaris Parkway, this property offers the perfect blend of peaceful rural living and convenient commuting. A definite must see for anyone looking for acreage, functionality, and room to grow!

3581 County Road 172, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Cheyenne A Peck ---- Howard Hanna - Main Office

Selling Office: Realty Forward.

$372,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Michael T Pankuch
Tucked away in the peaceful countryside, this charming 3-bedroom, 2 full bathroom bi-level home offers space, functionality, and country living at its finest. Situated on 2 scenic acres, the property features a walkout fully finished basement, providing versatile living space perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or hosting guests. Step inside to find a warm and inviting layout with generously sized bedrooms and updated bathrooms. The fully enclosed lanai offers the perfect retreat to enjoy the surrounding nature—ideal for morning coffee or evening sunsets. Outside, you'll find a large 30 x 38 barn complete with upstairs storage water and electric—perfect for hobbies, a workshop, or extra space for equipment. An RV carport adds convenience for travel enthusiasts or extra covered storage and is also equipped with a 30-amp service. This property is perfect for those seeking a blend of quiet rural living with the amenities of a well-equipped home. Room to roam, work, and relax—all in one country haven.

6410 Township Road 84, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Michael T Pankuch ---- RE/MAX Revealty

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC.

$353,100
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Patricia K Jackson
Well maintained 3-bedroom 2 bath home on 2+Acres with Full Basement and 2 car attached garage! Updates Include: Flooring; Roof, gutters & downspouts, water heater, basement waterproofing system with warranty, sump pump 2025; water filtration system 2023; Updated kitchen sink & counter & backsplash 2022; fenced rear yard 2020; Windows 2019; Heating/Cooling Units 2019/2021; Siding & doors 2017; Large Open Living Areas. Stainless kitchen appliances. Owner suite with his & hers closets. Large 12x23 Shed and Chicken Coup. The seller is requesting property to be marketed for 7 days. Highest and best offers will be considered on Monday, October 6, 2025 at 2pm. Please leave offers open until the next business day.

5171 US Highway 42, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Patricia K Jackson ---- RE/MAX Genesis

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC.

$350,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Janice Darmody
Open House This Saturday 5/2 @ 10am - 12pm. Everyone says they want land, updates, and location and almost no homes actually deliver all three. This one does! and conveniently located just 45 min. to Columbus. More than 2,000 sqft of living space (auditor will be updated in August), 3 bedroom, 2 full baths, open floor layout, tornado/safe room, set on 1.23 acres, this property offers the space buyers are looking for without sacrificing convenience. Inside, the home opens up beautifully with an open floor layout that creates a natural flow between the living, dining, and kitchen spaces. It's bright, functional, and designed for entertaining. The remodeled kitchen is both stylish and practical, featuring updated finishes and all appliances including Wine/beverage fridge, microwave, range and Samsung touchscreen refrigerator. Throughout the home, you'll notice the care and attention to detail including; Freshly painted interior, newer LVP floors, Updated bathrooms. A versatile family/rec room for relaxing or entertaining, and a cozy reading nook perfect for quiet moments or a home office setup. The layout offers comfort and flexibility for a variety of lifestyles. Step outside and enjoy your own space with a new backyard deck, ideal for morning coffee, evening gatherings, or simply taking in the peaceful surroundings. Beyond what you can see, the important updates have already been handled: Recently updated well Leviton electrical panel Durable metal roof And recent updates throughout that make this home truly move-in ready This is a home that offers more than just features! It offers versatility. Space where it matters. Updates where it counts and a location that keeps you connected.

7382 U.S. 42, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Janice Darmody ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

$343,900
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Kaleb Packer
Enjoy the feel of country living with modern updates throughout! The kitchen features new cabinets, countertops, range, and refrigerator, offering a fresh space for cooking and entertaining. The home includes one full bathroom on the main level and one upstairs, both fully updated with new tubs, vanities & fixtures. All five bedrooms are upstairs, along with the laundry area. New LVP flooring runs through the main living areas, with new carpet in the bedrooms. Outside, the 2-acre lot offers a large backyard and wooded area for added privacy. The covered back deck and fire pit provide a great setup for entertaining. Additional improvements include a new metal roof and siding installed in 2025, newer vinyl windows, and a large shed for storage. Listing agent is employed by and has business affiliations with the seller.

4260 Township Road 99, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kaleb Packer ---- I Heart Real Estate

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$335,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Erin C Kelty
Motivated sellers!!! This loved and well cared for 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch is the perfect place to call home, sitting on 1.8 acres with room for kids, pets, and play. Inside, you'll find fresh paint and new flooring (2020) that create a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The spacious walk-out basement is ideal for a family room, game room, or extra storage—whatever best fits your family's needs. Important updates include a brand-new roof (2023), newer windows (2021), and a new well (2018), giving you peace of mind for years to come. Conveniently located just 6 minutes from I-71 and 30 minutes from Columbus, you can enjoy country living without giving up quick access to the city. This move-in-ready home is waiting to be filled with new memories. Located in the desirable Highland School District. Schedule your private tour today.

4089 State Route 314, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Erin C Kelty ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

Selling Office: Keller Williams Consultants.

$330,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Lucille M Titus
MOTIVATED SELLER/AGENT OWNED! Fully renovated Cape Cod cedar home in the gated Candlewood Lake community consists of 1,500 acres of resort-style living with 24/7 security. Double lot with wraparound deck, wooded views, wildlife, and stunning sunsets. Highlights & Upgrades: ✔ NEW Samsung appliances (incl. Smart Fridge) ✔ NEW LVP flooring, gas furnace and gas hot water unit ✔ NEW roof, gutters w/leaf guards, & fresh exterior paint ✔ NEW 12x16 shed w/electric (matches home) ✔ NEW mini-split HVAC units in upstairs bedrooms and 4-Season Room ✔ Detached extra deep 2-car garage + outside RV/boat parking ** Sag in Living Room ceiling has been repaired. Community Perks: 2 pools, private beach, tennis/pickleball, basketball, lodge, boating, kayaking, fishing, trails, and year-round events. High-speed internet available. Move-in ready—modern comfort meets vacation-style living! Property is just one street from the lake! Walking distance to pool, tennis/pickleball courts and lodge. See List of Improvements in Document Tab.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 2, Lots 321/315 Unit Unit 2, Lots 321/315, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Lucille M Titus ---- Red 1 Realty

Selling Office: Real Estate & Auction Services.

$325,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Caitlyn Mulroy
Discover your dream home in the Central Ohio Collection, beautiful new homes for sale in Knox County and Morrow County, Ohio. Our new-construction homes are situated in two picturesque recreational lake communities, Apple Valley and Candlewood Lake, and offer up to 5 beds, 3 baths, and 2,737 sq. ft. Our designer-curated Looks offer a beautiful and cohesive interior in your new home. Crafted with exceptional quality and attention to detail, each of our new homes in the greater Columbus area are offered in one of our new interior design Looks: Farmhouse, Loft, Classic, or Elements, ensuring cohesive, designer-curated finishes for a stylish and comfortable living space tailored to your preferences. With new homes for sale in Knox and Morrow counties, this is the perfect opportunity to make living in the home of your dreams a reality. Offered By: K. Hovnanian Central Ohio, LLC The Water Lily offers: Well-equipped kitchen featuring Elkins White cabinets & floating shelves. Vast center island & Meridian Gray quartz countertops. Open great room & dining area creates seamless flow. Functional home office for working remotely. Private Extra Suite for overnight guests. Spacious primary suite & bath featuring walk-in closet. Inviting covered deck for relaxing outdoors. Finished basement with rec room & bath.

281/282 Stanford Court 8 Unit 8, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Caitlyn Mulroy ---- Redfin Corporation

Selling Office: LakefrontLivingRealty-LakeTeam.

$325,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Caitlyn Mulroy
Discover your dream home in the Central Ohio Collection, beautiful new homes for sale in Knox County and Morrow County, Ohio. Our new-construction homes are situated in two picturesque recreational lake communities, Apple Valley and Candlewood Lake, and offer up to 5 beds, 3 baths, and 2,737 sq. ft. Our designer-curated Looks offer a beautiful and cohesive interior in your new home. Crafted with exceptional quality and attention to detail, each of our new homes in the greater Columbus area are offered in one of our new interior design Looks: Farmhouse, Loft, Classic, or Elements, ensuring cohesive, designer-curated finishes for a stylish and comfortable living space tailored to your preferences. With new homes for sale in Knox and Morrow counties, this is the perfect opportunity to make living in the home of your dreams a reality. Offered By: K. Hovnanian Central Ohio, LLC The Oleander offers: Breathtaking Elkins White cabinets & Aristokraft floating shelves. Large center island & Meridian Gray quartz countertops. Elegant dining area for family meals. Spectacular great room for entertaining guests. Private home office for peace & quiet. Pristine primary suite featuring dual walk-in closets. Primary bath with dual sinks & chrome finishes. Gorgeous covered patio for hosting friends and family!

141 Picadilly Drive 8 Unit 8, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Caitlyn Mulroy ---- Redfin Corporation

Selling Office: Real Estate Showcase, RES.

$322,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Sandy L Raines
Discover effortless lake community living in this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch set within the private, gated community of Candlewood Lake. Designed with an open-concept floor plan, this home features updated finishes, Pergo flooring throughout, and expansive living and dining areas filled with natural light. The finished lower level provides versatile bonus space--perfect for a media room, home office, gym, or guest overflow--plus an unfinished, discreet hidden storage area for utilities, a workspace or the tube for your boat! Situated on two parcels, the home offers added space and privacy while granting access to all the sought-after amenities of Candlewood Lake, including boating, swimming, tennis, and year-round recreation. A move-in-ready opportunity in one of the area's most desirable lake communities, just outside the city of Columbus.

7326 State Route 19, Unit 2, Lot 281/282 Unit Lot 281/282, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Sandy L Raines ---- The Raines Group, Inc.

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Services.

$320,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Scott R Noblet
This Beautiful Country Retreat Offers a 3 Bedroom, 2 Full Bath Home in Mt. Gilead on 5.32 Scenic Acres with 1,566 Sq Ft of Finished Living Space, a Full Basement with Outside Entry, and the Potential to Split the Lot for an Additional Home Site. Enjoy the Peace and Privacy of Country Living with a Nice Blend of Open Space, Mature Surroundings, and Room to Explore, Garden, Play, or Simply Relax. The Home Features a Fantastic Great Room Floor Plan with Vaulted Ceilings, a Spacious Open Feel, Mostly Drywall Upgrades, Quality Carpet, and a Functional Layout Designed for Comfortable Everyday Living. The Owner's Suite Offers a Private Retreat with His & Hers Closets, a Large Master Bathroom Featuring His & Her Vanities, Garden Tub, and Separate Shower. Just Outside is where this Property truly shines. Step onto the Large 14x26 Rear Deck overlooking the Beautiful Acreage -- perfect for Morning Coffee, Entertaining Friends & Family, or Enjoying the Peaceful Country Setting. The Property also includes a Garden Barn and Plenty of Space for Outdoor Activities, Gardening, Recreation, or Future Possibilities. Located in Mt. Gilead, this Property provides the perfect balance of Privacy and Convenience. Enjoy Nearby Outdoor Recreation including Mt. Gilead State Park for Boating, Fishing, Hiking, and Camping, along with Local Dining, Community Events, Parks, and Small-Town Charm. With Easy Access to I-71, you're just a convenient drive from Columbus while also having quick access to Northern Ohio destinations.

4625 County Rd 98, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Scott R Noblet ---- EXP Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Di Lusso Real Estate.

$320,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Caitlyn Mulroy
Discover your dream home in the Central Ohio Collection, beautiful new homes for sale in Knox County and Morrow County, Ohio. Our new-construction homes are situated in two picturesque recreational lake communities, Apple Valley and Candlewood Lake, and offer up to 5 beds, 3 baths, and 2,737 sq. ft. Our designer-curated Looks offer a beautiful and cohesive interior in your new home. Crafted with exceptional quality and attention to detail, each of our new homes in the greater Columbus area are offered in one of our new interior design Looks: Farmhouse, Loft, Classic, or Elements, ensuring cohesive, designer-curated finishes for a stylish and comfortable living space tailored to your preferences. With new homes for sale in Knox and Morrow counties, this is the perfect opportunity to make living in the home of your dreams a reality. Offered By: K. Hovnanian Central Ohio, LLC The Water Lily offers: Cozy Extra Suite perfect for overnight guests. Palatial kitchen with Elkins White cabinets & floating shelves. Impressive island and Cararra Miksa quartz countertops. Inviting dining area and gorgeous great room for entertaining guests. Private home office for working from home. Pristine primary suite with generous walk-in closet. Spa-like primary bath with dual sinks & chrome finishes.

165/166 Waldemar Court 8 Unit 8, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Caitlyn Mulroy ---- Redfin Corporation

Selling Office: Realistar.

$310,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Craig Buehler
CHARMING MOVE-IN READY RANCH ON 5+ ACRES IN MOUNT GILEAD! Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch perfectly situated on over 5 scenic acres, partially wooded for added privacy and natural beauty. Enjoy peaceful country living while relaxing on the inviting front porch with your favorite glass of lemonade. Step inside to find brand-new carpeting, freshly painted walls, and new luxury vinyl plank flooring in the kitchen and baths. The open-concept kitchen and dining area make entertaining a breeze, and the spacious family room is filled with natural light. The owner's suite features its own private full bath, and the convenient first-floor laundry (washer and dryer remain!) adds extra ease to daily living. The basement offers endless potential for additional living space or storage. An oversized 2-car garage provides plenty of room for vehicles, tools, and hobbies. Recent updates include a newer furnace '23. Nestled on a quiet road with serene views, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and charm—just minutes from town. Move right in and start enjoying the peaceful country life you've been dreaming of!

4565 Township Road 59, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Craig Buehler ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$310,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Caitlyn Mulroy
Discover your dream home in the Central Ohio Collection, beautiful new homes for sale in Knox County and Morrow County, Ohio. Our new-construction homes are situated in two picturesque recreational lake communities, Apple Valley and Candlewood Lake, and offer up to 5 beds, 3 baths, and 2,737 sq. ft. Our designer-curated Looks offer a beautiful and cohesive interior in your new home. Crafted with exceptional quality and attention to detail, each of our new homes in the greater Columbus area are offered in one of our new interior design Looks: Farmhouse, Loft, Classic, or Elements, ensuring cohesive, designer-curated finishes for a stylish and comfortable living space tailored to your preferences. With new homes for sale in Knox and Morrow counties, this is the perfect opportunity to make living in the home of your dreams a reality. Offered By: K. Hovnanian Central Ohio, LLC The Goldenrod offers: Charming kitchen with Elkins Stone Gray cabinets & floating shelves. Vast island with Carrara Miksa quartz countertops. Welcoming dining area and great room with vaulted ceilings. Private primary suite with spacious walk-in closet. Primary bath with stylish white quartz countertops & matte black finishes. Versatile covered deck for outdoor enjoyment. Attached 2-car garage for vehicles and storage.

106 Liverpool Drive 2 Unit 2, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Caitlyn Mulroy ---- Redfin Corporation

Selling Office: LakefrontLivingRealty-LakeTeam.

$309,990
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Caitlyn Mulroy
Discover your dream home in the Central Ohio Collection, beautiful new homes for sale in Knox County and Morrow County, Ohio. Our new-construction homes are situated in two picturesque recreational lake communities, Apple Valley and Candlewood Lake, and offer up to 5 beds, 3 baths, and 2,737 sq. ft. Our designer-curated Looks offer a beautiful and cohesive interior in your new home. Crafted with exceptional quality and attention to detail, each of our new homes in the greater Columbus area are offered in one of our new interior design Looks: Farmhouse, Loft, Classic, or Elements, ensuring cohesive, designer-curated finishes for a stylish and comfortable living space tailored to your preferences. With new homes for sale in Knox and Morrow counties, this is the perfect opportunity to make living in the home of your dreams a reality. Offered By: K. Hovnanian Central Ohio, LLC The Water Lily offers: Pristine home office & second floor loft. Extra Suite for overnight guests. Striking kitchen with Elkins cabinets & Aristokraft floating shelves. Elegant Meridian Gray quartz countertops & pendant lights above island. Open great room & dining area with access to covered deck. Refined primary suite & bath with white quartz countertops & dual sinks.

124 Picadilly Drive 8 Unit 8, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Caitlyn Mulroy ---- Redfin Corporation

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.