Refine Search
Sort by
$269,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Erin C Kelty
Back on the market through no fault of the sellers, this beautiful split level home in the desirable Northwood subdivision of Mt. Gilead. 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 full baths, sitting on a generous near half acre lot with mature trees. Roof is only two years old. Some new windows with transferable warranty. 1 year old HVAC, all appliances convey including washer & dryer, and refrigerator is brand new! Beautiful hardwood floors upstairs and the lower level has water resistant laminate flooring. Wood burning fireplace in lower level works and has an electric blower. Ring doorbell conveys. House even has an electric fence for your pets. Lots of storage! Pool table is included. Home is within walking distance to schools as well as the beautiful downtown Village of Mt. Gilead. Enjoy parades and community events, summer farmer's markets, shops and dining.

346 Lee Street, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Erin C Kelty ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

$324,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Paige Bryant
New Price • New Opportunity! Now offered on approximately 0.65 acres across three parcels, this beautifully maintained ranch offers the perfect balance of space, privacy, and flexibility. Looking for even more room? Two adjoining parcels are also available for purchase, giving buyers the opportunity to expand to approximately 1.13 acres if desired. Major updates have already been completed, including newer windows, furnace and central air, water heater, water softener, gutters, sump pump, radon mitigation system, and a whole-house generator for added peace of mind. Designed for convenient one-level living, the home features first-floor laundry, a spacious primary suite with a walk-in closet and private ensuite bath, and an inviting semi-open floor plan centered around a cozy fireplace. Natural light fills the bright three-season room, creating the perfect place to relax with your morning coffee or unwind in the evening while overlooking the peaceful backyard. Step outside onto the rear deck and enjoy the surrounding nature and privacy. The partially finished basement offers incredible flexibility with a full bath, wet bar area, potential for an egress bedroom, and plenty of space for a second family room, recreation area, home office, or multigenerational living. An insulated workshop with its own heat source is located just off the garage, making it ideal for hobbies, projects, additional storage, or a dedicated workspace. Life in Candlewood Lake is about more than just the home. Enjoy boating, fishing, kayaking, jet skiing, swimming, private beaches, tennis, pickleball, parks, walking trails, a 24/7 fitness center, and the peace of mind of living in a gated community. The monthly HOA also includes water, sewer, trash, and 24/7 security. **1 year lender paid temp rate buy down available with a select lender *ask your agent for details!**

7326 State Route 19 Unit 2 Lots 198-200 Unit Unit 2 Lots 198-200, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Bryant ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

$469,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Kathleen M Short
One of the best views on lake. Escape to the serene beauty of Candlewood Lake with this inviting 3-bedroom, 3-full bath log cabin nestled in Mt. Gilead. Perfectly blending rustic charm with modern comfort, this home offers a true lakeside retreat. Step inside to discover a warm, open-concept living area featuring natural wood finishes, exposed beams, and large windows that flood the space with sunlight while framing breathtaking water views. The fully equipped kitchen is ideal for preparing family meals or entertaining guests, flowing seamlessly into the cozy dining and living spaces. Each of the three bedrooms is generously sized, offering privacy and comfort for family and friends. The three full bathrooms provide convenience and a touch of luxury, perfect for a weekend getaway or full-time lake living. Outside, relax on the deck or patio while soaking in panoramic views of Candlewood Lake, or enjoy water activities just steps from your door. The property also offers ample outdoor space for gatherings, barbecues, and making lifelong memories. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat, a family getaway, or an investment property in one of Mt. Gilead's most desirable lakefront areas, this log cabin delivers charm, comfort, and spectacular scenery. Also jetted tub in owners suite. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of lakeside paradise. Schedule your showing today!

7326 Ohio 19 Unit 3 Lot 49 Unit Unit 3 Lot 49, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kathleen M Short ---- RE/MAX Impact

$295,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Susan B Tavenor
Seller is motivated to sell! After 25+ years of enjoying the friendly, relaxed lifestyle living of Candlewood Lake, the family has moved on. It's YOUR time to enjoy mornings on your balcony with views of the lake while waving at neighbors who drive by on golf carts. Truly a friendly community with monthly activities for all ages! On 3 lots this property has plenty of space for yard games or potentially an additional outbuilding. Close to the back gate for easy access to I-71 and to South Dock. Take advantage of 2 pools, tennis and pickle ball courts, fishing, boating, playgrounds, private beach, and nature trails. Monthly assessments include Water, Sewer, Trash service. Seller willing to negotiate how to assist the next owner with flooring allowance. Call for your private tour today!

7326 State Route 19 U3 L60-62, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Susan B Tavenor ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

$999,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Connie S Schubert
Rustic charm abounds in this beautiful Candlewood lakefront home! This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home features a first floor open floor plan, showcasing a full kitchen with high-end, Viking and Sub Zero stainless steel appliances, Corian countertops, dining area, and a living room with gas stone fireplace. This room opens to an airy, glass filled sunroom with a spectacular view of the lake. The first floor also features a master suite with attached full bath, and a second bedroom and additional half bath. The fully finished lower level includes a large recreation/family room, an additional sunroom overlooking the lake, as well as 2 additional bedrooms, and a luxurious full bath, with combination glass enclosed steam/shower room and standalone bathtub. Extending from the first floor is a spacious outdoor deck, with a stone fireplace, perfect for entertaining. Additional multilevel decks extend from the house, with stairs leading to a large dock with two boat lifts, which also includes an adjacent, private lakefront sauna. A 2-car detached garage completes this fantastic property. Two boats and a golf cart are negotiable. Your family and friends will enjoy all the unique features this must-see home has to offer!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 1, Lot 187 Unit Unit 1, Lot 187, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Connie S Schubert ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty

$40,000
⋅ Janelle Marie Gasaway
Sellers are eager to move - make them an offer. Looking for a place to unwind and enjoy the summer? This Candlewood Lake property is ready for you. Hard to find double-lot with mature trees in the back of RV/camper unit comes with a 2006 Fleetwood Enterprises (Terry 330 FKDS) 33 ft. camper with roof-over and deck, firepit, gravel driveway, and 10x12 storage shed. Roof over includes new ceiling fans to keep you cool all summer. Open from April-November, get full access to private pool, basketball/pickleball courts, playground, community room, showers and laundry, plus all the other amenities Candlewood Lake has to offer. It's the perfect ''base camp'' for your summer weekends. Come see why life is better at the lake!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 4, Lots 278/279 Unit Unit 4, Lots 278/279, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Janelle Marie Gasaway ---- Cutler Real Estate

$515,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Tara Welch
This is the kind of home buyers wait for in Candlewood. Tucked into a private wooded setting, this fully remodeled home has been thoughtfully updated over the past five years and feels like something out of a magazine. The kitchen stands out with black custom cabinetry, exposed beam, farmhouse sink, gas range, butcher block island, beverage fridge, and a built-in coffee bar that blends high-end design with everyday living. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a calm, finished feel with a shiplap accent wall and a spa-style bathroom featuring dual vanities and a full marble walk-in shower. The finished basement adds an additional 867 square feet of living space for entertaining or guests, while the outdoor setup is built for relaxing with a deck, pergola swing, patio, and wooded backdrop that provides rare privacy. Homes like this don't come up often in Candlewood, and when they do, they don't last. Listing agent is related to seller.

7326 Ohio 19 10 Unit 10, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Tara Welch ---- Dream Huge Realty

$1,385,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Richard J McClusky
Open house Sunday 9/20/2026 from 1:00 to 3:00 pm. Sellers are motivated! It's time to hit the lake! Looking for a lakefront home in a private quiet community within a 45 minute drive from Columbus? This custom Amish-built retreat offers the ideal waterfront lifestyle. Situated on over half an acre with a private dock on a quiet cove. Enjoy all the water activities such as boating, skiing, tubing, wakeboarding, kayaking, canoeing, and fishing right from your backyard! The home features a chef's kitchen, a spacious main-level primary bedroom suite with spa-like bath and direct laundry access, and another bedroom/office flex space. The finished lower level includes two bedrooms which brings the total to 4 bedrooms. A jack-and-Jill bath separates the LL bedrooms, a wood-burning fireplace, bar area, and versatile bonus space, plus ample storage and a workshop garage. Additional highlights include a whole-home generator, multiple porches, including a screened porch with serene lake views perfect for year-round comfort and easy waterfront living. The lawn equipment items are negotiable with an acceptable offer. Sellers are offering some closing cost assistance to the Buyer with a reasonable offer. Ring surveillance cameras in use. Agent owned.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 7 lots 80/81 Unit Unit 7 lots 80/81, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Richard J McClusky ---- e-Merge Real Estate

$15,000
⋅ Kathleen M Short
Beautiful wooded lot located in the desirable gated community of Candlewood Lake. This private parcel offers a peaceful, natural setting surrounded by mature trees--perfect for building your dream home or weekend getaway. Situated on a quiet street, the lot provides added privacy and a serene atmosphere, with nearby green space enhancing the sense of seclusion. Enjoy all the benefits of lake living, including access to boating, fishing, swimming, and scenic shoreline views. Candlewood Lake is a well-maintained community featuring resort-style amenities such as a private lake, beach, swimming pools, clubhouse, walking trails, and sports courts. With year-round recreational opportunities and a welcoming neighborhood environment, this property is ideal for both full-time living or a relaxing retreat. Conveniently located just a short drive from Columbus and surrounding areas, this wooded lot offers the perfect balance of nature, privacy, and community living. $164.24/ Month HOA covers water, sewer, trash, & 24/7 security.

7326 State Route 19 9 Lot 74 Unit 9 Lot 74, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kathleen M Short ---- RE/MAX Impact

$362,500
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Jeff Stuttler
AMAZING OPPORTUNITY: This rare 3-story Victorian brick home offers over 5,000 square feet of living space, blending timeless character with modern updates. The interior features 4 bedrooms, plus 2 additional bonus bedrooms on the third floor, 2 full bathrooms, multiple living spaces/sunrooms, original oak floors and trim, zoned heating and cooling, and 2 laundry locations. Recent updates include a new roof in 2022, new kitchen flooring/backsplash, and fresh paint throughout. The exterior features a manicured lot with several outdoor living spaces, including a back deck and front porch, as well as a detached garage for storage. Enjoy living within walking distance to local shops and dining.

217 W High Street, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Jeff Stuttler ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

$11,000
⋅ Paige Bryant
** MOTIVATED SELLER!!! **Welcome to Candlewood Lake--one of Central Ohio's most sought-after private, gated communities offering true resort-style living year-round. This beautiful wooded lot is perfectly situated on a quiet cul-de-sac, providing both privacy and a peaceful setting. It has a ravine at the rear of the property and backs up to green space that cannot be built on--giving you even more room to enjoy the natural surroundings. Candlewood Lake offers an unmatched lifestyle with endless amenities right at your fingertips. Spend your days boating, fishing, swimming, water skiing, or tubing on the lake, or relax at the beach or community swimming pools. Enjoy scenic nature trails, as well as tennis, basketball, and pickleball courts, playgrounds, and a community fitness center. Residents also have access to a stunning community lodge overlooking the lake, along with a variety of events and activities throughout the year. With 24/7 gated security, this community provides both comfort and peace of mind. Whether you're looking to build your dream home or a weekend retreat, this lot offers the perfect opportunity to be part of a vibrant, amenity-rich community.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 7, Lot 310 Unit Unit 7, Lot 310, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Bryant ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

$798,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Connie S Schubert
Beautifully renovated lakefront contemporary home, complete with a large, detached garage and huge workshop/storage area! Located in a nicely wooded, park-like setting on two large lots, and situated at the end of a quiet, secluded lakefront cove, this home features a dramatic, 2-story living room with a large, floor to ceiling stone fireplace that serves as the centerpiece. An adjacent full kitchen and dinette with all-new cabinets, stone countertops, and stainless steel appliances, a combination mud/laundry room, a dedicated den/TV room, as well as a large bedroom and full bath, complete the first floor spaces. A dramatic open staircase leads upstairs to the master bedroom, with a walk-in closet, a dramatic ceramic tiled full bath, and an additional two bedrooms. All-new hardwood flooring ties all the spaces together throughout the house. Downstairs is a full basement and a 2-1/2 car garage. Outside, the brand-new deck overlooks large trees and the quiet cove below, with two boat docks. Sip your morning coffee enjoying the shaded lake cove and wildlife in this must-see home!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 2, Lots 1-2 Unit Unit 2, Lots 1-2, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Connie S Schubert ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty

$1,099,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ John Dible
Wake up to water views every day in this 2,700 sq.ft. lakefront home, ideally situated on a rare 1.3-acre parcel within the gated Candlewood Lake community. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence or a weekend escape, this property delivers the space, privacy, and lifestyle that lakefront living is all about. Spread across five combined lots, this generously sized property offers something increasingly hard to find on Candlewood Lake: room to breathe. Two wooded lots provide a buffer from the primary roadway with only 4 homes located on this private cul-de-sac. Mature trees fill the property offering shade, comfort and privacy. Substantial and easy to access shoreline (no hills or stairs) features over 500 square feet of dock surface and a boat slip. Sunsets over the water from your private dock create a postcard perfect view. Launch a kayak from your own dock, cast a line before breakfast, or simply unwind on the water's edge -- this is lake life the way it's meant to be lived. Candlewood Lake isn't just a place to live -- it's a lifestyle. Residents enjoy access to a private lodge, two swimming pools, a fitness center, tennis, basketball and pickleball courts, playgrounds, a beach, hiking and nature trails, and of course, some of the best boating, skiing, and fishing in the region. This gated community offers the rare combination of resort-style amenities and small-town Ohio charm, just a short drive from Mount Gilead and within reach of Columbus. At nearly 2,700 square feet, this well-maintained home, with a recently remodeled exterior, offers comfortable, flexible living space suited to both everyday life and entertaining guests. With 22 years of history, it offers the character and established landscaping that only comes with time. It represents an excellent opportunity for a buyer looking to build equity in one of Ohio's most desirable lake communities.

7326 State Route 19 U8 L232-236 Unit U8 L232-236, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : John Dible ---- AO Real Estate

$998,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Connie S Schubert
This visually stunning, premier lakefront log home on a beautiful Candlewood Lake cove is a must see! The large kitchen has all stainless-steel appliances and Corian countertops with integral Corian kitchen sink. A dramatic great room features a massive stone fireplace as the focal point, with a spacious open concept visually connecting both the kitchen and dining area. All of this opens from sliding glass doors to a dramatic wrap-around deck, with beautiful views of the lake. A large bedroom and full bath are also located on the first floor. Upstairs, a second-floorloft overlooks the great room below, and leads to two additional, fully private bedrooms and another full bath. The lower walk-out level has been completed renovated, featuring heated LVT floors, and a large, open concept family room and rec room opening to a walkout covered porch. An additional bedroom, full bath, and office nook are also located on this level. From both the first-floor deck and lower-level porch, stairs lead down to the spacious private dock, with two fully covered boat slips and electric lifts. A two-car garage, separate storage shed, and a paved golf cart path provides easy access to the lake from the driveway and garage. Always be on vacation in this outdoor lover's dream!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 9, Lots 327-328 Unit Unit 9, Lots 327-328, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Connie S Schubert ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty

$12,500
⋅ Jennifer S Bump
At the end of this Cul de sac, you will find open land awaiting your dream home!! At just under a quarter of an acre, the mowing wont take long and you only have to enjoy your place of peace and the surrounding community. Candlewood lake has all the amenities for a busy life filled with plans and events or to find a quiet place to fish! Whether it's boating, fishing, hiking, sharing recipes or just enjoying fireworks, Candlewood has a lot to offer! Bring a golf cart or boat and join the parades come summertime!! Home Owners association fees cover the Water/Sewer and Trash bill as well as security and upkeep of the community. Buyer is responsible for the $1300 new member fee and any and all tap fees for water/Sewer and electric.

7326 Ohio 19 1 lot 93 Unit 1 lot 93, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Jennifer S Bump ---- Howard Hanna - Main Office

$625,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Connie S Schubert
This beautiful, nearly 3,000 square foot cottage-style lakefront home features a picturesque view of the lake from two large, entertainer's decks located on both the upper and lower levels. An open floor plan with an island kitchen, dinette, and living room features a wood beam cathedral ceiling and, as the centerpiece, a newly installed, stone-wrapped woodburning fireplace. Luxury LVT vinyl flooring is located throughout the house. Also on the first floor are 2 bedrooms and a full bath. The newly renovated, walkout lower level features a large family/recreation room with full wet bar, as well as a full kitchen, two dining areas, and an additional bedroom and full bath. Steps from the lower-level lead down to the private boat dock. Newer items include all kitchen appliances, central air conditioning, roof, gas furnace, lower-level deck, and retaining wall. A 2-car detached garage, storage shed, beautiful landscaping and a concrete drive round out this must-see property! Come enjoy living the lake life at Candlewood Lake!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 1, Lots 169-170 Unit Unit 1, Lots 169-170, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Connie S Schubert ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty

$489,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Anthony Glen Reed
This stunning 2022 Craftsman ranch first-tier property delivers the effortless lifestyle. Set on a rare .62-acre double lot, the property offers exceptional outdoor space for entertaining, recreation, gatherings, and evenings by the fire pit. Designed for easy, single-story living, the home features an open and spacious floor plan with 9-foot ceilings, abundant natural light, and a seamless flow between living, dining, and kitchen spaces. The electric fireplace adds warmth and character to the great room. The large primary bedroom is privately positioned on its own side of the floor plan and includes a generous walk-in closet and ensuite bath--creating a peaceful retreat separate from the home's additional bedrooms. Built for comfort and efficiency, the property offers natural gas for the furnace and stove/oven (with built-in air fryer), plus the added peace of mind of a whole-house generator. A full basement with an egress window and a completed bathroom provides tremendous potential for future living space or storage. A dedicated laundry and mudroom adds convenience to daily life, and all appliances--including the washer and dryer--are included, ensuring an easy transition for the next owner. Located inside one of Ohio's most desirable gated communities, residents enjoy 24-hour security and an unmatched outdoor lifestyle. Candlewood Lake offers two pools, tennis, pickleball, lakeside lodge, playgrounds, nature trails, a marina, and a year-round calendar of community events. Whether you prefer an active lifestyle or peaceful retreat, this community offers both. With an incredible location, Craftsman architecture, a large single-floor footprint, and extra land for privacy and outdoor living, this home represents the perfect blend of comfort, space, recreation, and serenity. Whether full-time or part-time, it delivers the heart-of-the-lake lifestyle so many dream of--yet rarely find this close to the water. (At least 2 photos have been digitally enhanced.)

7326 State Route 19 Unit 9, Lots 220 & 221 Unit Unit 9, Lots 220 & 221, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Anthony Glen Reed ---- LakefrontLivingRealty-LakeTeam

$17,500
⋅ Kate E Shulaw
Discover the perfect place to build your getaway or forever home inside the sought-after Candlewood Lake gated community. This spacious 0.46-acre property (two side-by-side 0.23-acre lots) sits near the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, offering privacy, wooded charm, and close proximity to the water. Candlewood Lake is known for its peaceful atmosphere--never overcrowded--while still offering fantastic amenities for year-round enjoyment. Residents enjoy a private lake, community pool, beach areas, clubhouse, tennis and pickleball, playgrounds, and plenty of space to slow down and reconnect with nature. Golf carts are welcome, making it easy to cruise to the water or spend the day on the lake. With available utilities and a low-maintenance lifestyle, this is the ideal spot to build your dream lake home, vacation retreat, or investment property. All of this is offered with a $161/month HOA that maintains the security, roads, and amenities that make Candlewood Lake so special. Enjoy lake living, small-community charm, and the quiet you've been looking for -- all just a short drive from Columbus.

210 Candlewood 210, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kate E Shulaw ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols

$17,500
⋅ Julie Schnuerer
Discover the perfect opportunity to build your dream retreat on two spacious lots located within the sought-after gated community of Candlewood Lake. This private setting not only offers peace and natural beauty but also gives you access to an incredible array of amenities. Enjoy boating, water skiing, and fishing on the sparkling lake, or spend your days relaxing at the lodge, swimming pool, or sandy beach area. Stay active with tennis and pickleball courts, hiking, and scenic nature trails, all just steps from your future home. Northmor Schools add to the appeal, making this an ideal spot for year-round living or a weekend getaway. With so much to offer, these lots provide the perfect blend of recreation, relaxation, and community.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 3 Lot 149-150 Unit Unit 3 Lot 149-150, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Julie Schnuerer ---- Sluss Realty Company

$665,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Connie S Schubert
Beautiful Candlewood lakefront home! This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home features a large first floor plan, with a full kitchen, bedroom, and full bath. A spacious living room is highlighted by a vaulted, cathedral ceiling with open stairs leading to a large loft above. From here, 3 large sliding glass doors open to a spectacular, 270-degree wrap-around deck with expansive, elevated views of the lake. A fully finished, walkout lower level has a large primary bedroom, as well as a full bath and additional guest bedroom. The fully landscaped property with water features and a large backyard has no dock access, but directly overlooks the lake waterfront, with a wonderful front-row seat to the annual Candlewood Lake July 4th fireworks spectacular! A 2-car attached garage and detached storage shed completes this fantastic property. Enjoy all the amenities Candlewood Lake has to offer, including boating, fishing, kayaking, lodge, swimming pool, tennis courts, and numerous walking and hiking trails!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 3, Lots 47-48 Unit Unit 3, Lots 47-48, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Connie S Schubert ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty