Refine Search
Sort by
140 N Stanley Street, Bellefontaine
$227,000
⋅ Malia K Hughes
Expand your investment portfolio with this income-producing, two-unit property at 140 N Stanley Street in Bellefontaine! Conveniently located near downtown, shopping, and eateries, with easy highway access, this multi-family property offers spacious layouts and separately metered utilities. The first-floor unit features 2 bedrooms, an oversized kitchen, a laundry room with washer/dryer hookups, central heat and air conditioning, and covered front and rear porches. The upper unit offers 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and generous living, dining, and kitchen areas, with electric heat throughout. Off-street parking at the rear adds convenience. The upstairs unit is currently vacant and ready for a new tenant, offering an opportunity to establish your own rental terms. All utilities are separate. Whether adding to your rental portfolio or exploring your first investment property, this duplex deserves a look. Call today to schedule your private tour!

140 N Stanley Street, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Malia K Hughes ---- Key Realty

235 N Pine Street, Lakeview
$370,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Paige Duff
Conveniently located just one mile from the Indian Lake bike bath and boat ramp! Welcome home to this beautiful 3 bed, 2 bath home in Lakeview at Woodland Park Estates. The owner's suite features a walk-in closet and en suite bathroom. The rec room includes a nice pool table and TV. The kitchen features beautiful cabinetry and stainless-steel appliances. The 3-car garage is a great space for parking and extra storage. Woodland Park Estates offers many amenities including a walking path, pond, shelter house with stone fireplace, playground & dog agility park. Enjoy peaceful neighborhood living just minutes from all the fun Indian Lake has to offer! HOA fee is $50/month and includes maintenance of common area, insurance, electric poles.

235 N Pine Street, Lakeview

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Duff ---- Choice Properties Real Estate

5416 State Route 274 E, Rushsylvania
$349,900
5 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Lori Lynn
Nearly 4 acres, a BRAND NEW 24 x 32 pole barn, 5 bedrooms, and numerous updates! Enjoy peaceful country living with room to spread out in the Benjamin Logan School District! The impressive new pole barn features a concrete floor and offers plenty of space for vehicles, equipment, storage, or a workshop. Inside, you'll find new flooring, fresh paint, updated lighting, newer windows, new 200 amp electrical service, and a new water softener and reverse osmosis system. The kitchen includes a refrigerator and range, while the convenient first floor laundry makes everyday living easier. The flexible floor plan features three bedrooms on the main level and two additional bedrooms upstairs with a walk through layout, offering possibilities for guests, a home office, or additional living space. A basement provides even more storage, and the outdoor deck is a great place to relax and enjoy the surrounding acreage. With nearly 4 acres to enjoy, a brand new pole barn, and so many recent improvements, this Rushsylvania property offers the space, flexibility, and country setting you've been looking for!

5416 State Route 274 E, Rushsylvania

Listing Courtesy of : Lori Lynn ---- Keller Williams Consultants

112 W Newell Street, West Liberty
$269,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Marlo J Capuano
Rare opportunity in quaint village of West Liberty. 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths with an oversized 2 car attached garage! Stroll to downtown in less than 5 minutes for coffee, ice cream & more! Easy walk to 2 town parks w/playgrounds, splash pad, and ball fields. Owners renovated in 2024 with all new flooring thru-out including easy maintenance LVP in living areas and wall to wall carpet in bedrooms, addition of second full bath into first floor owners suite featuring walk in shower with built in bench. 2 new HVAC units one for each level! Lots of new lighting throughout including ceiling fans in living room & owners bedroom. Updated drywall in many rooms, New water heater , new refrigerator, newer Bosch ultra quiet dishwasher, laundry tub added to mud room, fresh paint & more. Huge backyard features gorgeous row of peonies in the spring ! Owners sad to leave the love they put into this home but job change calls them south. West Liberty community features wonderful events throughout the year -a fantastic place to call home. Hurry to see this one! (Listing agent related to owner)

112 W Newell Street, West Liberty

Listing Courtesy of : Marlo J Capuano ---- Berkshire Hathaway HS Pro Rlty

117 Wilgus Street, Russells Point
$169,900
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Chris Reed
SMALL PACKAGE, BIG POSSIBILITIES! TWO PARCELS INCLUDED! This charming Indian Lake getaway packs a BIG punch! Completely renovated and loaded with character, this studio-style bungalow features gorgeous pine walls and ceilings, a beautifully appointed kitchen with custom cabinetry, birch countertops, open shelving, newer appliances, and a large Ruvati sink! The cozy sleeping loft is the perfect place to recharge after a day on the lake! THE BIG BONUS? AN ADJOINING BUILDABLE LOT IS INCLUDED! Imagine the possibilities--your own boat storage building, garage, or additional outdoor living space! Whether you're looking for a weekend retreat, vacation getaway, or investment opportunity. (Adjacent buildable lot at 239 Second Street parcel # 52-032-05-16-000 is directly behind the bungalow and is INCLUDED in the list price.)

117 Wilgus Street, Russells Point

Listing Courtesy of : Chris Reed ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

11406 Kickapoo Path, Lakeview
$249,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Malia K Hughes
Welcome to Indian Lake! This fun, fully furnished getaway is located in the desirable Chippewa area--just a short golf-cart ride from the Moose Lodge, ice cream, pizza, Brown Bean Coffee, Dollar General, boat docks, the park, and more! Situated on four lots, the property features a charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage with three covered porches, a private yard, woodshed, and an oversized heated and insulated garage/workshop. Recent improvements include a new HVAC system, updated bathroom, PEX plumbing, composite decking, awnings, concrete patio, and water softener. Everything you see at the time of showing conveys, making this property truly turnkey. Move right in and enjoy ice fishing this winter, then get ready to experience everything Indian Lake has to offer throughout the spring and summer. Call today for your private tour!

11406 Kickapoo Path, Lakeview

Listing Courtesy of : Malia K Hughes ---- Key Realty

548 Center Avenue, Bellefontaine
$224,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Bryn L Daring-Stewart
This charming two-story property features approximately 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath, with a versatile layout and a convenient location just minutes from State Route 33. The main floor features a welcoming front room with an open feel leading into the original dining area, a kitchen, laundry area, and a large main-floor bedroom. The second floor offers two additional bedrooms, including a loft-style room with a closet and another private bedroom with its own door and closet. Original character can be found throughout the home, including the covered front porch with classic columns and the home's historic proportions and details. The property also includes a cool, old-fashioned cellar with stone and concrete elements that reflect the age and history of the home. The property is B-1 zoned with an interesting opportunity for an entrepreneur, home-office user, professional, or buyer looking for a property with flexibility and visibility. Situated on a corner lot with room for parking and easy access to State Route 33, this property has a unique combination of historic character, practical space, and potential for the next owner to make it their own.

548 Center Avenue, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Bryn L Daring-Stewart ---- ROYER REALTY LLC

5459 County Road 20, Rushsylvania
$299,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Heidi Baker
This charming 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath farmhouse offers the perfect blend of rural tranquility and flexible living space. Enjoy peaceful sunrise views from the spacious eat-in kitchen, where east-facing windows overlook open countryside. The home features a first-floor owner's suite complete with a private bath, walk-in closet, laundry hookups, and plumbing already in place for a future soaking tub. Upstairs, you'll find two additional bedrooms, while the rear of the home offers valuable flex space ideal for a home office, exercise room, playroom, storage area, or second living room. Adding incredible value, a separate parcel located just across the county road features a massive 60' x 40' pole barn equipped with electric, water, and partial concrete flooring. Inside, two enclosed rooms provide endless options for a workshop, office, storage, hobby space, or future business use. With plenty of room to add a garage, additional outbuildings, or animals, this property offers the opportunity to create the mini farm you've always dreamed of or customize the space to fit your own vision. Whether you're seeking a country retreat, hobby farm, or simply room to spread out and enjoy the outdoors, this unique property is ready to welcome you home.

5459 County Road 20, Rushsylvania

Listing Courtesy of : Heidi Baker ---- Bell Hankins Realty Group, LLC

617 High Avenue, Russells Point
$269,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Tallie McKinney
Get ready to fall in love with a home that is anything but ordinary! From the massive lofted primary suite above the garage to your own backyard pool retreat, this home delivers space and personality with plenty of room to relax and entertain. You are welcomed inside by the bright, spacious layout that brings comfort from the moment that you swing through the door. Outside, summer living takes center stage with the above ground pool and covered deck. One can also enjoy a warm cup of coffee in front of the fireplace or on the open front deck on those cooler fall mornings! The two-car garage and full, unfinished basement boast ample storage space. Resting in the heart of Russell's Point, you can enjoy easy access to boating, beaches, parks, dining, shopping and more! From pool days to lake days, this home is ready to make every day living feel like a getaway. Call today!

617 High Avenue, Russells Point

Listing Courtesy of : Tallie McKinney ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

2388 State Route 47 E, Bellefontaine
$324,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Chelsey K Bailey
Move-in ready and possession at closing! This charming 3 bedroom, 1 bath, 1.5 story cabin-style home features approximately 1,421 sq. ft. of living space, a full basement and sits on 1.082 acres with a barn, and plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. The first floor offers a functional layout with a kitchen, dining room, living room, bedroom with walk-in closet, and first floor laundry. Upstairs, you'll find one to two additional bedrooms plus room that provides the opportunity to add a second bathroom. The home includes an electric range, refrigerator, microwave, portable dishwasher, washer, dryer, and water softener, all of which convey with the property. Recent updates include: foundation walls, rear deck, electrical, and PEX plumbing. Conveniently located less than 5 minutes from Bellefontaine, SR 33, and Benjamin Logan Schools. Great combination of country living and easy access to town.

2388 State Route 47 E, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Chelsey K Bailey ---- Bell Hankins Realty Group, LLC

111 W Miami Street, Degraff
$239,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Malia K Hughes
Welcome to this charming 1940s cottage in the Village of DeGraff, featuring Tudor-inspired architectural details and timeless character throughout! This move-in-ready home offers 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, original hardwood flooring, main-floor laundry and a full, partially finished basement that provides additional living and storage space. Outside, you'll appreciate the mature landscaping, fenced backyard, two-car detached garage and a wood privacy fence added in 2024. Valuable updates include a new furnace, central air conditioning and water heater in 2023, updated plumbing in 2024 and brand-new basement windows. Conveniently located approximately 12 minutes from the Honda Transmission Plant, 16 minutes from KTH Parts in St. Paris, 15 minutes from Bellefontaine and 21 minutes from Sidney. With its storybook charm, thoughtful updates and inviting outdoor spaces, this delightful home is ready for its next owner. Call today to schedule your private tour!

111 W Miami Street, Degraff

Listing Courtesy of : Malia K Hughes ---- Key Realty

10334 County Road 153, East Liberty
$269,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Chelsey K Bailey
Well-maintained ranch-style home located on the edge of Middleburg. This home offers 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and situate on 1.5 acres in the Benjamin Logan School District. Range, refrigerator, dishwasher, washer, dryer all convey with home! Enjoy the large front porch, spacious and partially fenced in back yard, attached one-car garage, pellet stove, chicken coop, and pear, apple and cherry trees! Numerous updates include: roof (2019), siding (2020), electrical (2018), plumbing (2019), flooring (2018), kitchen (2019), bathrooms (2018), shed (2018), chicken coop (2019), porch (2020), furnace (2023), insulation added to attic 2020, and water pump (2025). Conveniently located just minutes from SR 33, approximately 10 minutes to Honda, and 30 minutes to Dublin.

10334 County Road 153, East Liberty

Listing Courtesy of : Chelsey K Bailey ---- Bell Hankins Realty Group, LLC

824 Ridgeview Drive, Bellefontaine
$280,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Hannah Newlon
Welcome to 824 Ridgeview Drive! This turn-key 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath split-level home is nestled in an established Bellefontaine neighborhood, just minutes from Mary Rutan Park. The comfortable layout and inviting feel make this a home you can move right into and enjoy. Thoughtfully updated and well cared for, the flooring was replaced in 2020, interior walls and trim were freshly painted in 2026, along with the deck, railings, shutters, and soffits. The bathroom was remodeled in 2024, kitchen appliances were replaced in 2025, and the garbage disposal and kitchen sink were replaced in 2026. The home also features a 2017 furnace and 2015 water heater. Come take a look and see what makes this one feel like home!

824 Ridgeview Drive, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Hannah Newlon ---- Key Realty

11414 Hiawatha Path, Lakeview
$258,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Elizabeth A Roby
Welcome to your lake lifestyle! This beautifully updated home sits just steps from Indian Lake and offers the space, convenience, and entertainment features you've been looking for. The property includes three parcels, creating an expansive lot with plenty of room to enjoy, entertain, and make your own. Inside, the open kitchen provides a welcoming gathering space, while the garage is set up for fun with pool, foosball, and plenty of room to host the ultimate Football Sunday. In the past four years, sellers have completed upgrades including a new fence, new appliances, new A/C, new furnace, and a new water softener system. With its close proximity to the water, oversized three-parcel lot, thoughtful updates, and incredible entertainment setup, this Indian Lake property is ready to enjoy!

11414 Hiawatha Path, Lakeview

Listing Courtesy of : Elizabeth A Roby ---- Keller Williams Consultants

309 Zanesfield Road, West Liberty
$259,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ V. Patrick Hamilton
Prepare to be amazed the moment you step inside! From the outside, you may never expect to see the beautifully updated interior that awaits. This well-maintained home in the quaint Village of West Liberty offers a unique blend of charm, style, and functionality throughout. The heart of the home is the stunning open concept main living area, where beautiful hardwood floors, cathedral ceilings and skylights create a bright, airy and inviting space. The large room seamlessly combines the living room, dining area and kitchen, making it perfect for everyday living or entertaining. The stylish kitchen features 42-inch cabinets, a center island with seating, a fashionable backsplash, and stainless-steel appliances including a range, refrigerator, microwave, and dishwasher. The main level offers two bedrooms, an updated bathroom and a spacious laundry room. The lower level adds even more versatility with a third usable bedroom featuring an egress window for added safety. The remainder of the basement provides excellent storage space and includes built-in shelving. A huge bonus is the oversized two-car garage, offering plenty of room for vehicles plus space for a workshop, crafts, hobbies or additional storage. A concrete driveway extends from the front of the home to the back alley, providing abundant off-street parking and added convenience. Located in the charming Village of West Liberty with easy access to Bellefontaine, Urbana and surrounding communities, this home offers the perfect combination of small-town living and convenient access to nearby cities. Most updates were completed in 2018, and the roof was replaced in 2019. Come see this unexpected gem! You'll be amazed by what awaits you inside! Plus, the home is located directly next door to Marie's Candies! 'Sweet!'

309 Zanesfield Road, West Liberty

Listing Courtesy of : V. Patrick Hamilton ---- REMAX Alliance Realty

417 E Brown Avenue, Bellefontaine
$210,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Libby Zimmerman
Located near Brown Park and the community swimming pool, this charming renovated 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath two-story home features a large fenced yard, covered front porch, great curb appeal with numerous updates including a convenient first floor laundry. & half bath, updated kitchen cabinetry and flooring, formal dining room and a versatile space adjacent to the kitchen which can be a study, mudroom or exercise room. Second floor includes an owner's suite with ensuite bath and walk-in closet as well as two additional bedrooms and an updated hall bath. Full appliance package in kitchen including range, refrigerator, microwave, dishwasher, reverse osmosis drinking water system and garbage disposal. Other updates when remodeled in 2019 include roof, siding, front and exterior doors, HVAC units, PEX plumbing, GFCI and tamper resistant wiring, hardwired smoke detectors, window screens and some flooring. Water softener is owned and stays. Washer & Dryer do not stay. The garage/outbuilding is quite old and is used primarily for storage of mowing and lawn equipment, etc. Actual SF is now 1560 since the property was remodeled in 2017. See Broker's Remarks.

417 E Brown Avenue, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Libby Zimmerman ---- ZIMMERMAN REALTY

11162 Maple Drive, Lakeview
$399,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Paige Duff
Welcome to lake life with LOW property taxes! This charming waterfront cottage with a brand-new roof offers the perfect place to relax, entertain, and enjoy everything the lake has to offer. You'll love the owner's suite featuring a remodeled en suite bath and a slider door that opens to a private, serene patio. A second bedroom and additional updated full bath provide plenty of space for family and guests. The remodeled kitchen features stainless steel appliances, an eating area, and flows to the cozy living room with wonderful open-water views. A large sliding glass door fills the room with natural light and leads to the deck overlooking the lake, spacious yard, two boat slips, and 80' of waterfront. The new 28'x16' concrete waterside patio with a large pergola is perfect for summer dinners, cocktails, and evenings by the water. The property also features a gated driveway and enough parking space for 5 cars! Two storage sheds offer plenty of room for lake toys and lawn equipment. Whether you're boating, entertaining, or simply relaxing by the water, this is a wonderful place to enjoy lake living with family and friends. Seller is providing a one-year home warranty through Old Republic.

11162 Maple Drive, Lakeview

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Duff ---- Choice Properties Real Estate

501 N Madriver Street, Bellefontaine
$339,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Malia K Hughes
Welcome to 501 N. Mad River Street, where untouched historic beauty, rich woodwork and solid craftsmanship take center stage. Offering more than 2,760 square feet of living space, this grand Bellefontaine residence showcases the quality and architectural detail rarely found in newer homes. Soaring ceilings, beautiful parquet flooring, substantial solid-wood trim and timeless character reflect an era when homes were built with artistry and made to last. The spacious floor plan includes 3-4 bedrooms, with a flexible main-level bedroom option, and two beautifully updated full bathrooms. Modern improvements complement the home's historic charm, including 46 replacement windows, a fully remodeled kitchen, renovated bathrooms, custom blinds, a security camera system and a newly added concrete patio. The full basement with egress access provides generous storage and additional functionality. Outside, you'll find a 35x24 detached two-car garage, two additional storage sheds and inviting space to relax or entertain. Conveniently located with easy access to downtown Bellefontaine's dining, shopping and community amenities, this remarkable home offers the perfect blend of preserved character, enduring craftsmanship and modern comfort. Schedule your private tour and experience its beauty firsthand!

501 N Madriver Street, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Malia K Hughes ---- Key Realty

115 S Sandusky Street S, Rushsylvania
$269,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Thomas J Few
Step into a home with a story to tell. Built in 1907 and offering more than 3,000 square feet, this 4-bedroom, 2-bath Rushsylvania home showcases the craftsmanship and character that's increasingly difficult to find. From the moment you enter, you'll notice the soaring ceilings, oversized windows, substantial wood trim, beautiful pocket doors and hardwood floors that have been stripped and refinished throughout--preserving the warmth and character of the home's original design. The main level offers spacious, light-filled living and dining areas, a welcoming kitchen with abundant cabinetry, stainless steel appliances and butcher-block island, plus a walk-in pantry with built-in shelving. Flexible additional rooms provide space for a home office, den, playroom or whatever fits your lifestyle. Upstairs, generously sized bedrooms continue the home's bright, airy feel, while the vintage-inspired bath features a clawfoot tub and separate water closet. Throughout the home, you'll find the kind of architectural details that give a century-old property its personality--original-style doors, wide moldings, built-ins and distinctive spaces you simply don't get with today's cookie-cutter construction. And while the character has been preserved, important improvements have already been addressed. The furnace, hot water tank and sump pumps were updated in 2025. The front porch has been updated, lower-level front windows replaced, and the hardwood floors have been stripped and beautifully re-stained throughout. Outside, enjoy a covered front porch made for a morning coffee or quiet evening, along with a manageable yard.

115 S Sandusky Street S, Rushsylvania

Listing Courtesy of : Thomas J Few ---- e-Merge Real Estate

8483 County Road 97, Belle Center
$229,900
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Chelsey K Bailey
Welcome to this beautifully updated 4 bedroom, 1 bath home situated on a .275 acre lot in the Benjamin Logan School District! Offering 1,498 square feet of living space, the first floor features a living room, dining room, kitchen, bathroom / utility room. Upstairs, you'll find four bedrooms providing plenty of closet space. The home was updated in 2026 with new flooring, fresh paint throughout, new kitchen cabinets, countertop, sink, siding, drywall, 200 amp breaker box and more! Outside, enjoy a rear deck perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The property also features a 30' x 20' pole barn and a 1-car garage, providing excellent storage and workspace options.

8483 County Road 97, Belle Center

Listing Courtesy of : Chelsey K Bailey ---- Bell Hankins Realty Group, LLC

1121 Knowlton Road, Bellefontaine
$379,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Kyle E Springs
Welcome to 1121 Knowlton Road, an immaculate three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath home set amid lush perennial gardens, mature trees, and a beautifully manicured lawn. The main level offers a versatile formal dining room, a spacious kitchen with custom built-ins and a charming breakfast area, and an impressive great room featuring vaulted ceilings, warm paneled walls, additional built-ins, and a gas fireplace with a striking stone hearth. The generous owner's suite includes dual closets and a private bath, while two additional bedrooms and a full hall bath complete the main floor. Designed for both relaxation and entertaining, the lower level features a recreation area with a wet bar, abundant storage, flexible hobby or office space, a half bath, and a utility room. Ideally located near Mary Rutan Park, the Shawnee Trace walking path, and the new Hoffman Pool scheduled to open in summer 2027, this exceptionally maintained, two-owner home reflects true pride of ownership and presents a rare opportunity to own on a street where houses rarely come for sale.

1121 Knowlton Road, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Kyle E Springs ---- ZIMMERMAN REALTY