Colonial Hills Homes under $400,000

Colonial Hills Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Colonial Hills, a charming subdivision nestled in the heart of Worthington, Ohio, within the scenic Franklin County. This delightful community offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, making it an ideal place for families, young professionals, and retirees alike.

Colonial Hills is renowned for its tree-lined streets, friendly neighbors, and a strong sense of community. The subdivision boasts a variety of homes, many of which are attractively priced under $400,000. Whether you’re seeking a cozy starter home or a spacious residence for your growing family, you’ll find a diverse selection of properties that cater to different tastes and lifestyles.

The homes in Colonial Hills are characterized by their classic architecture, inviting yards, and thoughtful layouts that maximize space and comfort. Many properties feature updated kitchens, expansive living areas, and beautiful outdoor spaces, perfect for entertaining or simply enjoying a quiet evening under the stars.

Living in Colonial Hills means you’re just moments away from Worthington’s vibrant downtown, where you can explore charming boutiques, savor delightful dining options, and enjoy community events throughout the year. The area is also home to excellent schools and parks, making it an exceptional choice for families looking to settle down in a nurturing environment.

If you’re searching for an affordable yet charming place to call home in Worthington, Colonial Hills should be at the top of your list. Discover the perfect balance of comfort, community, and convenience in this inviting neighborhood today!

Newest Colonial Hills Homes under $400,000

463 Kenbrook Drive, Worthington
$285,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Cynthia C MacKenzie
Charming 2BR ranch home in popular Colonial Hills! Inviting curb appeal and timeless character throughout. Fresh interior paint creates a bright, welcoming atmosphere, complemented by beautiful hardwood floors and classic crown molding. The spacious living room features a decorative fireplace and built-in shelving, adding warmth and character to the space. New flooring in the kitchen and laundry room! Enjoy relaxing or entertaining from the screened porch overlooking the deep lot, offering plenty of space for outdoor entertaining or to simply unwind. An attached 1-car garage provides added convenience and storage. Additional highlights include: New Roof '26, Furnace/AC '03, and Rosati Windows! Nestled in a wonderful neighborhood with mature trees, 2 parks, a creek, community clubhouse & sporting areas with a voluntary association that plans fun community events year round! Easy access to the shops and restaurants of Old Worthington!

463 Kenbrook Drive, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate
568 Loveman Avenue, Worthington
$400,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Leah A Bastin
CHARMING cape cod located in desirable Colonial Hills! Step into the breezeway entry, perfect mudroom or bonus space. This south facing home is flooded with natural light! Hardwood floors flow throughout the 1st floor. SPACIOUS living room opens to the BRIGHT dining area with bay window. Updated kitchen with white cabinetry, granite counter tops, SS appliances & pantry cabinet. LARGE 1st floor PRIMARY SUITE with walk-in closet & ensuite bath. The 2nd full bath is off the hallway. The upstairs 2nd bedroom provides ample space for a bedroom + flex area & a large closet. The FINISHED lower level provides additional living space including a home office + space to fit your lifestyle & additional storage area. The paver patio is the PERFECT spot to enjoy the FENCED backyard. Nothing to do but MOVE IN!

568 Loveman Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Leah A Bastin ---- Cutler Real Estate
5698 Indianola Avenue, Worthington
$305,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Rhiannon M Ferrari
Welcome home to one of Worthington's most charming hidden gems! Perfectly located in a popular area, this adorable 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home is full of character, style & updates that make it move-in ready. The bright, beautifully updated kitchen opens to inviting living spaces featuring gorgeous new laminate flooring throughout the first floor, creating a fresh, modern feel while maintaining all the home's charm. The updated bathrooms add the perfect finishing touch, making this home as functional as it is cute. Step outside and fall in love with the oversized backyard, complete with mature trees, a spacious patio, and a cozy fire pit perfect for summer evenings, entertaining friends, or relaxing with family. A full basement offering endless possibilities for storage, a home gym, or future finished living space. Whether you're buying your first home, downsizing, or simply looking for that perfect combination of location, charm, and value, this Worthington beauty checks all the boxes. All New carpet! Homes this cute in this location don't come along often!

5698 Indianola Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Rhiannon M Ferrari ---- EXP Realty, LLC
5550 Foster Avenue, Worthington
$389,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Janet Poling Reiss
Tucked into one of Worthington's most desirable neighborhoods, this charming Cape Cod offers the perfect blend of character, comfort, and opportunity. Situated in Colonial Hills on an oversized lot, the home provides both space to enjoy today and room to grow for the future. Inside, you'll find 1,364 square feet of inviting living space, featuring two comfortable main-level bedrooms, a third upstairs bedroom, and two full baths. A large deck offers the perfect setting for summer cookouts, while the adorable gazebo invites you to relax with a book, host friends, or simply enjoy the view of your expansive yard. The attached garage leading into the mudroom and laundry room provides convenience and functionality. With its unbeatable location near Old Worthington, shops, parks, and schools, this home is ready to welcome its next owner. Updates include: newly refinished hardwood floors and freshly painted thruout 2026, new AC, water heater, gas line 2025, new sewer line 2024, new roof and gutters 2021, new crawl space encapsulation, radon mitigation system, concrete driveway 2018.

5550 Foster Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Janet Poling Reiss ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs
Start Your Search