Candlewood Lake Homes under $500,000

Candlewood Lake Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Candlewood Lake, a picturesque subdivision nestled in the heart of Mount Gilead, Ohio, within Morrow County. This charming community is perfect for those seeking a serene lifestyle surrounded by nature, while still enjoying modern conveniences. With a stunning private lake at its center, Candlewood Lake offers a tranquil retreat where residents can indulge in boating, fishing, and leisurely strolls along the scenic waterfront.

The homes in Candlewood Lake are designed to cater to a variety of lifestyles, with many options available for under $500,000. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, a growing family, or looking to downsize, you’ll find a diverse selection of well-appointed properties that perfectly blend comfort and affordability. Many homes feature spacious layouts, updated kitchens, and beautiful outdoor spaces, ideal for entertaining and enjoying the breathtaking views of the lake and surrounding woods.

The community is not just about beautiful homes; it also boasts an array of amenities that enhance the living experience. Residents can take advantage of the clubhouse, swimming pool, and various recreational activities that foster a sense of community and connection among neighbors. With easy access to nearby parks, shopping, and dining options in Mount Gilead, Candlewood Lake truly offers the best of both worlds.

If you’re searching for a peaceful and welcoming community that provides a perfect balance of nature and convenience, look no further than Candlewood Lake. Explore the available homes today and discover your dream home in this idyllic setting!

Newest Candlewood Lake Homes under $500,000

7326 State Route 19 Unit 6, Lots 176-177 Unit Unit 6, Lots 176-177, Mount Gilead
$199,700
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Carol A Lessick
This affordable home has been completely updated with new flooring, paint, roof, gutters, and much more. Situated on double lot in fabulous Candlewood Lake, with year-round amenities - Boating, fishing, lodge, and more!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 6, Lots 176-177 Unit Unit 6, Lots 176-177, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Carol A Lessick ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty
7326 Ohio 19 9 Lot 14 Unit 9 Lot 14, Mount Gilead
$369,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Kathleen M Short
Welcome to this inviting 3-bedroom ranch in the serene Candlewood Lake community, just a short walk from the beach. Recently updated, the home features a 32 by 15-foot rear deck with a covered seating area and built-in Blackstone grill--perfect for entertaining. Additional highlights include a rear pavered patio (2024), a fire pit with seating (2025), and a covered front porch (2026). Inside, enjoy new flooring (2024), carpet (2023), a kitchen remodel (2024), and a brand-new laundry room (2026). Major updates like a new furnace and AC (2023-2024), windows (2026), and all new plumbing (2025),roof replaced (2018) make this home truly move-in ready. Don't miss your chance to call it yours!

7326 Ohio 19 9 Lot 14 Unit 9 Lot 14, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kathleen M Short ---- RE/MAX Impact
7326 State Route 19 Unit 8, Lot 15 Unit Unit 8, Lot 15, Mount Gilead
$395,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Connie S Schubert
Step into this beautiful, recently built, 1765 SF 4-bedroom, 2 bath ranch-style home in Candlewood Lake! Featuring a spacious, open concept great room/dining room/kitchen with vaulted ceilings and plenty of natural light, which serves as the home's primary centerpiece. This space opens to an expansive, partially covered outdoor deck overlooking the large backyard. Modern finishes and details are included throughout, including laminate wood flooring, quartz countertops, and all stainless-steel kitchen appliances. A large first-floor master bedroom with attached full bath and large walk-in closet, as well as 3 additional large bedrooms, another full bath, and laundry room complete the first floor. Additional numerous features include ceiling fans throughout, a full-sized basement, reverse osmosis water purification, concrete driveway, 2-car attached garage, and a storage shed. Enjoy all the amenities Candlewood Lake offers, including boating, fishing, community lodge and pool, tennis and basketball courts, fitness center, hiking trails, and so much more! Don't miss out on this gorgeous home! Furnishings are negotiable.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 8, Lot 15 Unit Unit 8, Lot 15, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Connie S Schubert ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty
7326 State Route 19 Unit 5, Lots 52-54 Unit Unit 5, Lots 52-54, Mount Gilead
$147,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Kimberly A Kovacs
SELLER IS RELOCATING AND MOTIVATED! Welcome to your lake retreat in the highly desirable gated community of Candlewood Lake! This charming 2 bedroom, 2 full bath home is situated on three spacious lots, offering added privacy and outdoor space to enjoy. Relax on the inviting front deck with your morning coffee or unwind while taking in breathtaking sunsets. Inside, you'll find a bright, open concept living room and kitchen featuring a beautiful vaulted wood ceiling and two skylights that fill the space with natural light. Recent updates include a newer heat pump, central air conditioning, and gutters. Experience the best of lake living with access to the private 250-acre lake, perfect for boating, fishing, kayaking, paddle boarding, countless outdoor adventures. Candlewood Lake offers an exceptional lifestyle with outstanding amenities including a swimming pool, private beach, pickleball courts, community lodge, walking trails, play ground and park for larger gatherings and year-round social events. Enjoy popular community gatherings such as Food Truck Fridays, Sundae Socials, the Annual Community Yard Sale, and many other activities that make this neighborhood so special. Conveniently located just one hour from Columbus, this home is the perfect full-time residence, weekend getaway, or vacation retreat. Don't miss your opportunity to enjoy everything Candlewood Lake has to offer!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 5, Lots 52-54 Unit Unit 5, Lots 52-54, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kimberly A Kovacs ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
7326 State Route 19 Unit 7, Lot 199 Unit Unit 7, Lot 199, Mount Gilead
$440,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Chelsea Visconti
Welcome to the kind of home that changes how you spend your free time. Perfectly positioned in Candlewood Lake's sought-after Tier 1 section, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers 2,184 square feet of comfortable living just moments from the water. Here, you're close enough to catch glimpses of the lake, hop on the golf cart, and be at the beach, pool, or boat ramp in just minutes. Inside, the spacious eat-in kitchen naturally becomes the gathering place, while two separate living areas offer flexibility for entertaining, relaxing, or hosting guests. The loft-style family room adds architectural character and creates a space that feels open, inviting, and unlike the ordinary. A first-floor primary suite features a private ensuite bath, oversized walk-in closet, and direct access to the laundry room, creating a layout that's as practical as it is desirable. Step outside and the lifestyle continues. Spend evenings around the stone fire pit, enjoy morning coffee beneath the gazebo, or let kids and pets roam the generous side yard. Every season offers another reason to be outside. Life in Candlewood isn't measured by amenities--it's measured by moments. Sunset golf cart rides. Last-minute boat cruises after work. Kids meeting friends at the playground. Neighbors gathering around the beach, pool, and clubhouse. Weekends that feel planned without ever having to leave the neighborhood. Whether you're spending the day boating, skiing, tubing, fishing, paddleboarding, swimming, playing pickleball or tennis, exploring the walking trails, or simply enjoying the energy of a community where people are outside connecting with one another, Candlewood offers a lifestyle that's difficult to replicate and even harder to leave. This isn't just a home near the lake. It's a place where everyday life starts feeling a little more like vacation.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 7, Lot 199 Unit Unit 7, Lot 199, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Chelsea Visconti ---- The Holden Agency
7326 State Route 19 U4, Lot 309 Unit U4, Lot 309, Mount Gilead
$29,000
⋅ Chelsea Visconti
Escape to Candlewood's Unit 4 RV section with this move-in-ready seasonal getaway! This lot includes a fully furnished 2008 Wildwood RV, a spacious 3-season room, laundry room with stackable washer and dryer, and a large shed with dedicated golf cart parking and additional storage. Enjoy every aspect of Candlewood - Lake, Pools, Playgrounds, Sport courts, Lodge, Beach, and many community events throughout the year!

7326 State Route 19 U4, Lot 309 Unit U4, Lot 309, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Chelsea Visconti ---- The Holden Agency
7326 State Route 19 Unit 10. 46 & 47 Unit Unit 10. 46 & 47, Mount Gilead
$59,900
⋅ Paige Bryant
Build your dream home on this beautiful double wooded lot totaling .52 acres in the desirable Candlewood Lake community! Ideally located just across from the stunning 250-acre lake, this property offers a fantastic location with the perfect blend of privacy and convenience. A culvert is already in place, and public water and sewer are available at the road for easy connection. Enjoy everything Candlewood Lake has to offer, including boating, fishing, swimming, a community beach, tennis, pickleball, basketball, a resort-style pool, a lodge for gatherings and events, and a 24/7 fitness center. Whether you're looking to build your full-time residence or the perfect weekend retreat, this property offers the opportunity to enjoy lake living and an abundance of amenities year-round. Don't miss your chance to own a spacious homesite in one of the areas most desirable locations! Agent related to seller.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 10. 46 & 47 Unit Unit 10. 46 & 47, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Bryant ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
7326 St Rt 19 Unit 8 Lot 123 Unit Unit 8 Lot 123, Mount Gilead
$264,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Ryan J Ruehle
Welcome to Candlewood Lake living at 7326 State Route 19, Unit 8, Lot 123! Nestled in the desirable gated Candlewood Lake community, this 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch offers the perfect blend of everyday comfort and vacation style living. Located on a quiet street just minutes from the water, you'll enjoy all the amenities that make Candlewood so special, including the lake, clubhouse, beach, and pool. Step inside to a spacious foyer that opens into an inviting living room and beautifully designed kitchen featuring wood floors, tall cherry cabinetry, granite countertops, tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and a center island perfect for gathering and entertaining. The easy flow floor plan makes everyday living a breeze. The full basement provides incredible flexibility with a partially finished layout offering additional living space, plus rooms that could be used as bedrooms, craft rooms, offices, or storage areas. Outside, you'll find a large backyard designed for relaxation and entertaining, complete with a patio area for cooking, a hot tub, beautiful landscaping, a storage shed, and a welcoming front porch. Recent updates include a metal roof and newer black-trimmed windows, adding both style and peace of mind. Don't miss your opportunity to enjoy year round living in one of the area's most sought-after lake communities!

7326 St Rt 19 Unit 8 Lot 123 Unit Unit 8 Lot 123, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Ryan J Ruehle ---- EXP Realty, LLC
7326 STATE ROUTE 19 U9 LOTS 31-32 Unit U9 LOTS 31-32, Mount Gilead
$479,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Kathleen M Short
Discover lakeside living in this inviting log cabin on Candlewood Lake. Bright, comfortable and updated with modern touches while preserving classic cabin character. New carpet in a bedroom (2023) New flooring in large front room (2023) Bedroom-to-office conversion with new flooring (2025) Exterior landscaping improvements and installed fire pit (2023-2025) New microwave & oven unit (2025) Updated lighting in main rooms Ideal for weekend getaways or full-time living, this property offers relaxed lake lifestyle with recent upgrades for comfort and convenience.

7326 STATE ROUTE 19 U9 LOTS 31-32 Unit U9 LOTS 31-32, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kathleen M Short ---- RE/MAX Impact
7326 State Route 19 U5 L98-100, Mount Gilead
$230,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Susan B Tavenor
BUYERS still Invited to tour house and check out the Resort-style living at Candlewood Lake! Buy NOW to enjoy the Pool, Tennis-Pickle Ball, Private Beach, Boating, Fishing, Nature Trails and variety of Community Events. Recently updated Ranch on 3 lots with NEW flooring and Freshly Painted. Attached Garage and Private Owner's Suite on one side features Large Bedroom with oversized walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms with full bathroom located on the other side of the house. With just over 2000 SF the open floor plan is great for entertaining! Large Kitchen and Living Room with an additional room that could be a Dining Room, Rec Room, or Private Office. Monthly HOA includes Water, Sewer, Trash, 24/7 Security. Seller including 1yr Home Warranty. Just 45min from Columbus - call for your private tour today!

7326 State Route 19 U5 L98-100, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Susan B Tavenor ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
7326 State Route 19 Unit 2 Lots 198-200 Unit Unit 2 Lots 198-200, Mount Gilead
$324,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Paige Bryant
This beautifully maintained ranch offers the perfect balance of space, privacy, and flexibility. Looking for even more room? Two adjoining parcels are also available for purchase, giving buyers the opportunity to expand to approximately 1.13 acres if desired. Major updates have already been completed, including newer windows, furnace and central air, water heater, water softener, gutters, sump pump, radon mitigation system, and a whole-house generator for added peace of mind. NO EXPENSE SPARED HERE! Designed for convenient one-level living, the home features first-floor laundry, a spacious primary suite with a walk-in closet and private ensuite bath, and an inviting semi-open floor plan centered around a cozy fireplace. Natural light fills the bright three-season room, creating the perfect place to relax with your morning coffee or unwind in the evening while overlooking the peaceful backyard. Step outside onto the rear deck and enjoy the surrounding nature and privacy. The partially finished basement offers incredible flexibility with a full bath, wet bar area, potential for 4th bedroom (has egress), and plenty of space for a second family room, recreation area, home office, or multigenerational living. An insulated workshop with its own heat source is located just off the garage, making it ideal for hobbies, projects, additional storage, or a dedicated workspace. Life in Candlewood Lake is about more than just the home. Enjoy boating, fishing, kayaking, jet skiing, swimming, private beaches, tennis, pickleball, parks, walking trails, a 24/7 fitness center, and the peace of mind of living in a gated community. **1 YEAR LENDER PAID TEMP RATE BUY DOWN AVAILABLE WITH SELECT LENDER *Ask your agent for details!**

7326 State Route 19 Unit 2 Lots 198-200 Unit Unit 2 Lots 198-200, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Bryant ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
7326 Ohio 19 Unit 3 Lot 49 Unit Unit 3 Lot 49, Mount Gilead
$469,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Kathleen M Short
One of the best views on lake. Escape to the serene beauty of Candlewood Lake with this inviting 3-bedroom, 3-full bath log cabin nestled in Mt. Gilead. Perfectly blending rustic charm with modern comfort, this home offers a true lakeside retreat. Step inside to discover a warm, open-concept living area featuring natural wood finishes, exposed beams, and large windows that flood the space with sunlight while framing breathtaking water views. The fully equipped kitchen is ideal for preparing family meals or entertaining guests, flowing seamlessly into the cozy dining and living spaces. Each of the three bedrooms is generously sized, offering privacy and comfort for family and friends. The three full bathrooms provide convenience and a touch of luxury, perfect for a weekend getaway or full-time lake living. Outside, relax on the deck or patio while soaking in panoramic views of Candlewood Lake, or enjoy water activities just steps from your door. The property also offers ample outdoor space for gatherings, barbecues, and making lifelong memories. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat, a family getaway, or an investment property in one of Mt. Gilead's most desirable lakefront areas, this log cabin delivers charm, comfort, and spectacular scenery. Also jetted tub in owners suite. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of lakeside paradise. Schedule your showing today!

7326 Ohio 19 Unit 3 Lot 49 Unit Unit 3 Lot 49, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kathleen M Short ---- RE/MAX Impact
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!