Candlewood Lake Homes for Sale

Candlewood Lake Homes for Sale

Welcome to Candlewood Lake, an enchanting subdivision nestled in the heart of Mount Gilead, Ohio, within the picturesque Morrow County. This serene community is a hidden gem for those seeking a tranquil lifestyle surrounded by nature’s beauty, while still being conveniently located near urban amenities.

Candlewood Lake is renowned for its stunning waterfront properties, offering residents breathtaking views and a plethora of recreational opportunities. Imagine waking up to the gentle sounds of nature, with the shimmering lake just steps from your door. Whether you enjoy fishing, boating, or simply soaking in the sun on a warm summer day, Candlewood Lake provides the perfect backdrop for a relaxed, outdoor lifestyle.

The homes for sale in this charming subdivision are as diverse as the community itself. From cozy cottages to spacious family homes, each property boasts unique architectural styles and modern amenities designed to cater to a variety of tastes and needs. Many homes feature open floor plans, updated kitchens, and expansive outdoor spaces, perfect for entertaining or unwinding after a long day.

Living in Candlewood Lake means becoming part of a welcoming community that values connection and camaraderie. With organized events and activities throughout the year, residents can easily forge lasting friendships and create cherished memories.

If you’re looking for a place that combines the tranquility of lakeside living with the warmth of a close-knit community, Candlewood Lake is the perfect destination. Explore the homes for sale today and discover your dream retreat in this idyllic Ohio subdivision!

Newest Candlewood Lake Homes for Sale

$624,999
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Zachary R Tominack
Welcome to one of the most private and breathtaking properties in Candlewood Lake! Nestled on nearly 1.2 wooded acres surrounded by mature trees and a scenic ravine, this custom Amish-built home offers over 3,000 square feet of beautifully finished living space. Quality craftsmanship shines throughout with hardwood floors, solid wood doors and trim, tongue-and-groove ceilings, vaulted ceilings, and a durable metal roof. The open floor plan features 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a stunning four-season addition surrounded by windows with peaceful wooded views. The primary suite includes a new custom walk-in shower. The finished lower level offers a spacious recreation room, kitchenette, two additional rooms with egress windows ideal for guest rooms or home offices, and abundant storage. Enjoy the private stamped concrete patio with a fire pit or work and play in the heated oversized detached garage featuring oversized doors and an RV charging station. Recent updates include the four-season addition, custom primary shower, waterproofed basement with sump pump and battery backup, stamped concrete patio, and new concrete driveway. Located in the gated Candlewood Lake community with a 250-acre private lake, beaches, marinas, pool, fitness center, pickleball and tennis courts, clubhouse, and Mt. Tabor Trail just steps away. This is a rare opportunity to own one of Candlewood Lake's most private and distinctive properties.

7326 State Route 19 10, Lots 73,74,75,76 Unit 10, Lots 73,74,75,76, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Zachary R Tominack ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
$525,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Mary K Sunderman
Get used to hearing, ''This is our favorite house in the community.'' The current owners certainly have. Perfectly nestled among the mature trees of Candlewood Lake with seasonal lake views, this beautifully maintained home has long been admired for its timeless charm, inviting outdoor spaces, and warm, welcoming feel. Designed for both everyday living and entertaining, the open-concept main floor features a spacious great room that flows seamlessly into the kitchen and dining areas. The first-floor primary suite offers comfort and convenience, while two additional bedrooms provide plenty of room for family and guests. The finished lower level adds exceptional flexibility with a large recreation room, full bathroom, and space ideal for movie nights, a home office, fitness area, or overnight visitors. Outdoor living is every bit as impressive, beginning with the welcoming covered front porch and continuing to the beautiful paver patio, where you'll enjoy peaceful mornings, summer evenings, and the beauty of this wooded lake community. The EXTRA DEEP (31' x 16') garage offers additional storage for lake toys, golf cart, tools, or a workshop. Garage door 9' (h)x 9'9'(w). This home has been thoughtfully updated for both style and peace of mind, including a new roof (2023), remodeled primary bath (2022), whole-house generator, new sump pumps with battery backups, new range (2025), and new microwave (2026). Whether you're looking for a full-time residence or the perfect weekend escape, you'll love the lifestyle Candlewood Lake offers with a private beach, boating, fishing, tennis, pickleball, swimming, and year-round community events. Homes like this rarely become available--and once you visit, you'll understand why so many people say it's their favorite in the community.

7326 OH State Route 19 Unit 9 Lots 33/34 Unit Unit 9 Lots 33/34, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Mary K Sunderman ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs
$29,700
⋅ Carol A Lessick
Affordable seasonal getaway at beautiful Candlewood Lake! Fishing, boating, pool, clubhouse, walking trails, park, and more! 3 lots with water, sewer, and electric. New decking. 16x10 storage shed with 2 lofts.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 4, Lots 245-247 Unit Unit 4, Lots 245-247, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Carol A Lessick ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty
$160,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Kimberly A Kovacs
Welcome to your lake retreat in the highly desirable gated community of Candlewood Lake! This charming 2-bedroom, 2 full bath home is situated on three spacious lots, offering added privacy and outdoor space to enjoy. Relax on the inviting front deck with your morning coffee or unwind while taking in breathtaking sunsets. Inside, you'll find a bright, open concept living room and kitchen featuring a beautiful vaulted wood ceiling and two skylights that fill the space with natural light. Recent updates include a newer heat pump, central air conditioning, and gutters. Experience the best of lake living with access to the private 250-acre lake, perfect for boating, fishing, kayaking, paddle boarding, countless outdoor adventures. Candlewood Lake offers an exceptional lifestyle with outstanding amenities including a swimming pool, private beach, pickleball courts, community lodge, walking trails, play ground and park for larger gatherings and year-round social events. Enjoy popular community gatherings such as Food Truck Fridays, Sundae Socials, the Annual Community Yard Sale, and many other activities that make this neighborhood so special. Conveniently located just one hour from Columbus, this home is the perfect full-time residence, weekend getaway, or vacation retreat. Don't miss your opportunity to enjoy everything Candlewood Lake has to offer!

53 Pembroke 5 Lots 52-54 Unit 5 Lots 52-54, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kimberly A Kovacs ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
$465,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Chelsea Visconti
Welcome to the kind of home that changes how you spend your free time. Perfectly positioned in Candlewood Lake's sought-after Tier 1 section, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers 2,184 square feet of comfortable living just moments from the water. Here, you're close enough to catch glimpses of the lake, hop on the golf cart, and be at the beach, pool, or boat ramp in just minutes. Inside, the spacious eat-in kitchen naturally becomes the gathering place, while two separate living areas offer flexibility for entertaining, relaxing, or hosting guests. The loft-style family room adds architectural character and creates a space that feels open, inviting, and unlike the ordinary. A first-floor primary suite features a private ensuite bath, oversized walk-in closet, and direct access to the laundry room, creating a layout that's as practical as it is desirable. Step outside and the lifestyle continues. Spend evenings around the stone fire pit, enjoy morning coffee beneath the gazebo, or let kids and pets roam the generous side yard. Every season offers another reason to be outside. Life in Candlewood isn't measured by amenities--it's measured by moments. Sunset golf cart rides. Last-minute boat cruises after work. Kids meeting friends at the playground. Neighbors gathering around the beach, pool, and clubhouse. Weekends that feel planned without ever having to leave the neighborhood. Whether you're spending the day boating, skiing, tubing, fishing, paddleboarding, swimming, playing pickleball or tennis, exploring the walking trails, or simply enjoying the energy of a community where people are outside connecting with one another, Candlewood offers a lifestyle that's difficult to replicate and even harder to leave. This isn't just a home near the lake. It's a place where everyday life starts feeling a little more like vacation.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 7, Lot 199 Unit Unit 7, Lot 199, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Chelsea Visconti ---- The Holden Agency
$929,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Deann S Brunke
MUST SEE!! Built on a double lot, this fabulous custom-Amish built Schlabach home in the private gated community of Candlewood Lake is only 2 years old. Sitting on almost 100' of lakefront, it has a large back yard with almost 1 acre of land and a custom 12x20 maintenance free dock with stunning views and a great place to hang out on those summer day and nights. The entry level open floor plan includes a dream kitchen with large island, that includes a white farmhouse sink, and amazing great room with stone gas fireplace and real walnut floors. This level also includes a primary suite with beautiful en-suite bath, that includes a giant jetted hydro massage tub, laundry room in the entry, 2 additional bedrooms with 1 full bath in between and a half bath just off the entry. The large screened-in porch overlooking the huge back yard with firepit is stunning and is right off the kitchen and the great room. The full unfinished basement is pre-plumbed for a full bath and has a Kinetico reverse osmosis water system.

7326 Ohio 19 Unit 2 Lots 11,12 Unit Unit 2 Lots 11,12, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Deann S Brunke ---- Go Realty
$14,000
⋅ Paige Bryant
Build your dream home on these beautiful adjoining lots totaling approximately 0.48 acres in the gated Candlewood Lake community! Offering a level building site and lined with mature trees for added privacy, this property is located just around the corner from the community's incredible amenities, making it easy to enjoy everything Candlewood Lake has to offer. Whether you're looking to build your forever home or a weekend retreat, these lots provide the perfect combination of peaceful surroundings and resort style living. Water and sewer are available through the community to tap into, making the building process even more convenient. Take a quick golf cart ride to the private lake for boating, fishing, kayaking, and jet skiing, or spend the day enjoying the community beaches, swimming pool, tennis and pickleball courts, basketball courts, parks, walking trails, clubhouse, and 24/7 fitness center. The gated community also provides the convenience of water, sewer, trash service, and 24/7 security through the HOA. For buyers looking for even more space, these parcels may also be purchased together with the adjoining ranch home, creating the opportunity to own approximately 1.13 acres in one of Candlewood Lake's most desirable locations. Don't miss this opportunity to build the home you've always envisioned while enjoying all the recreation, convenience, and natural beauty Candlewood Lake has to offer!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 2, Lots 196-197 Unit Unit 2, Lots 196-197, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Bryant ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
$29,000
⋅ Chelsea Visconti
Escape to Candlewood's Unit 4 RV section with this move-in-ready seasonal getaway! This lot includes a fully furnished 2008 Wildwood RV, a spacious 3-season room, laundry room with stackable washer and dryer, and a large shed with dedicated golf cart parking and additional storage. Enjoy every aspect of Candlewood - Lake, Pools, Playgrounds, Sport courts, Lodge, Beach, and many community events throughout the year!

7326 State Route 19 U4, Lot 309 Unit U4, Lot 309, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Chelsea Visconti ---- The Holden Agency
$189,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Rebecca Foy
Warning: Side effects of owning this home may include buying a boat, spending way too much time outside, and suddenly volunteering to host every summer get-together. Welcome to your new happy place! Located inside the gated Candlewood Lake community, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home sits on three lots (166-168), giving you a little extra breathing room and plenty of space for backyard games, bonfires, or simply enjoying your morning coffee before the lake starts calling your name. Inside the home, you'll find a bright, inviting layout that's easy to love, with comfortable living spaces, a kitchen equipped with an island and eat-in area, and a private primary suite that's ready to become your own little retreat after a day of sunshine and fresh air. Need space for hobbies, projects, or all the lake toys? You're covered. The detached garage features a dedicated workshop plus a separate garage/man cave space--perfect for tinkering, watching the game, or simply escaping for a little ''me time.'' A brand-new storage shed provides even more room to keep lawn equipment and outdoor gear organized. But let's be honest, the lifestyle is the real star here. Candlewood Lake is where weekends feel like mini vacations and neighbors become friends. Spend your days boating, fishing, swimming, playing pickleball, relaxing by the pool, or cruising around the community in your golf cart. With a private 250-acre lake, marina, beaches, clubhouse, walking trails, playgrounds, and year-round events, there's always something to do... or absolutely nothing at all, if that's more your style. Whether you're looking for your full-time home or the weekend escape you keep talking about, this one makes it easy to say yes. The only difficult decision? Lake day... or pool day?

7326 Ohio 19 Unit 5, lot 166, 167, 168 Unit Unit 5, lot 166, 167, 168, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Rebecca Foy ---- Real of Ohio
$59,900
⋅ Paige Bryant
Build your dream home on this beautiful double wooded lot totaling .52 acres in the desirable Candlewood Lake community! Ideally located just across from the stunning 250-acre lake, this property offers a fantastic location with the perfect blend of privacy and convenience. A culvert is already in place, and public water and sewer are available at the road for easy connection. Enjoy everything Candlewood Lake has to offer, including boating, fishing, swimming, a community beach, tennis, pickleball, basketball, a resort-style pool, a lodge for gatherings and events, and a 24/7 fitness center. Whether you're looking to build your full-time residence or the perfect weekend retreat, this property offers the opportunity to enjoy lake living and an abundance of amenities year-round. Don't miss your chance to own a spacious homesite in one of the areas most desirable locations! Agent related to seller.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 10. 46 & 47 Unit Unit 10. 46 & 47, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Bryant ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
$264,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Ryan J Ruehle
Welcome to Candlewood Lake living at 7326 State Route 19, Unit 8, Lot 123! Nestled in the desirable gated Candlewood Lake community, this 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch offers the perfect blend of everyday comfort and vacation style living. Located on a quiet street just minutes from the water, you'll enjoy all the amenities that make Candlewood so special, including the lake, clubhouse, beach, and pool. Step inside to a spacious foyer that opens into an inviting living room and beautifully designed kitchen featuring wood floors, tall cherry cabinetry, granite countertops, tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and a center island perfect for gathering and entertaining. The easy flow floor plan makes everyday living a breeze. The full basement provides incredible flexibility with a partially finished layout offering additional living space, plus rooms that could be used as bedrooms, craft rooms, offices, or storage areas. Outside, you'll find a large backyard designed for relaxation and entertaining, complete with a patio area for cooking, a hot tub, beautiful landscaping, a storage shed, and a welcoming front porch. Recent updates include a metal roof and newer black-trimmed windows, adding both style and peace of mind. Don't miss your opportunity to enjoy year round living in one of the area's most sought-after lake communities!

7326 St Rt 19 Unit 8 Lot 123 Unit Unit 8 Lot 123, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Ryan J Ruehle ---- EXP Realty, LLC
$1,199,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Connie S Schubert
Must-see premier Candlewood lakefront home! This 4-bedroom, 3 bath home features a large first floor open floor plan, showcasing a full kitchen with stainless steel appliances, countertop seating area, walk-in pantry, dining area, and a great room with wood burning/gas stone fireplace. This dramatic room also highlights a vaulted, cathedral ceiling with full glass sliding doors opening to the large deck with beautiful views of the lake. The first floor features the expansive primary bedroom suite with a full bath, large whirlpool tub, and his/her walk-in closets, plus one additional bedroom and another full bath. Upstairs, a large loft area overlooks the great room below, and features two additional bedrooms and a full bath. The full walkout basement is ready to be finished, featuring 9-foot ceilings and pre-plumbing for a full bathroom. Outside, a stone firepit overlooks the lakefront dock with a covered boatlift and large elevated roof deck. A 2 and ½ car attached garage, beautiful landscaping and an authentic custom-built treehouse completes this fantastic property. Enjoy all the amenities Candlewood Lake has to offer, including boating, fishing, kayaking, lodge, swimming pool, tennis courts, and numerous walking and hiking trails! THIS IS A MUST-SEE PROPERTY!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 7, Lot 126 Unit Unit 7, Lot 126, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Connie S Schubert ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty
Start Your Search