Millersport Homes under $400,000

Millersport Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Millersport, Ohio – a hidden gem nestled along the serene shores of Buckeye Lake. Known for its tight-knit community and picturesque landscapes, Millersport offers a delightful blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. With a rich history and a vibrant local culture, this quaint village is an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone looking to embrace a peaceful lifestyle.

One of the standout features of Millersport is its affordability in the housing market. For those seeking a new home without breaking the bank, you’ll be pleased to discover a variety of charming properties available for under $400,000. From cozy bungalows to spacious family homes, there’s something to suit every taste and budget. Many of these homes boast beautiful yards, perfect for outdoor gatherings or serene evenings under the stars.

In addition to its inviting homes, Millersport is surrounded by a wealth of recreational opportunities. Enjoy boating, fishing, and picnicking at Buckeye Lake State Park, or explore the scenic trails and parks that dot the area. The community hosts various events throughout the year, fostering a sense of belonging and camaraderie among residents.

With its affordable housing options and a lifestyle that encourages connection with nature and neighbors alike, Millersport is truly a place to call home. If you’re ready to embark on your journey to find the perfect property, let Millersport welcome you with open arms!

Newest Millersport Homes under $400,000

W Lancaster Drive, Millersport
$44,500
⋅ Brian J Thompson
EXCITING NEW CONSTRUCTION OPPORTUNITY IN BUCKEYE LAKE! Imagine creating your own lake-area retreat or investment property just steps from the charm and recreation of Buckeye Lake! This approximately 0.115-acre wooded lot is conveniently located across from Sellers Point and the picturesque shoreline walking and biking trail, offering easy access to the lake lifestyle. Currently zoned for two-unit residential uses, this parcel offers potential for a single-family residence or duplex development, subject to applicable zoning and building approvals. Seller-provided architectural concept drawings and engineered site plans are available, including proposed building locations, grading, drainage, and utility infrastructure. Water and sewer plans have received approval from the local water department. Gas, water, and electric are available in the area. Spend your days enjoying boating, fishing, nearby waterfront dining, entertainment, and everything this vibrant lake community has to offer. An excellent opportunity for builders, investors, or buyers looking to establish a presence near one of Central Ohio's most popular recreational destinations. All proposed construction remains subject to applicable zoning, permitting, and development approvals. Buyer to verify building requirements, utility connections, permitted uses, and all necessary approvals.

W Lancaster Drive, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Brian J Thompson ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
N Bank Road Lot #5 Unit Lot #5, Millersport
$44,500
⋅ Brian J Thompson
BUILD YOUR FUTURE NEAR BUCKEYE LAKE! This approximately 0.115-acre wooded parcel offers an exciting opportunity to own property in one of Central Ohio's favorite lake communities! Ideally located across from Sellers Point and the scenic Buckeye Lake shoreline walking and biking trail, this property puts boating, fishing, waterfront restaurants, and outdoor recreation within easy reach. Currently zoned for two-unit residential uses, the lot presents potential for new residential construction, including duplex development, subject to applicable requirements and approvals. Seller-provided architectural concept drawings and engineered site plans are available, including proposed building locations, grading, drainage, and utility infrastructure. Water and sewer plans have received approval from the local water department. Gas, water, and electric are available in the area. Just minutes from the North Shore boat launch and the many attractions surrounding Buckeye Lake, this is an appealing opportunity for builders, investors, or buyers seeking a place of their own near the water. All proposed construction remains subject to applicable zoning, permitting, and development approvals. Buyer to verify permitted uses, buildability, utilities, and all applicable requirements.

N Bank Road Lot #5 Unit Lot #5, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Brian J Thompson ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
North Bank Road NE Lots 1-4 Unit Lots 1-4, Millersport
$178,000
⋅ Brian J Thompson
RARE BUILDING & INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY NEAR BUCKEYE LAKE! Discover four adjoining parcels totaling approximately 0.46 acre, ideally situated across from Sellers Point and the scenic Buckeye Lake shoreline walking and biking trail. Currently zoned for two-unit residential uses, this wooded property offers exciting possibilities for builders, investors, and developers looking to capitalize on the appeal of this popular Central Ohio lake community. Seller-provided architectural concept drawings and engineered site plans are available, including proposed building locations, grading, drainage, and utility infrastructure. Water and sewer plans have received approval from the local water department. Gas, water, and electric are available in the area. Enjoy convenient access to the North Shore boat launch, waterfront dining, fishing, boating, entertainment, and the recreational attractions that make Buckeye Lake such a desirable destination. Whether you're envisioning new residential construction, duplex development, or a long-term investment, this property offers an outstanding opportunity to explore your vision near the lake. All proposed construction remains subject to applicable zoning, permitting, and development approvals. Buyer to verify permitted uses, building requirements, utility connections, and all applicable approvals.

North Bank Road NE Lots 1-4 Unit Lots 1-4, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Brian J Thompson ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
12073 Ninth Avenue, Millersport
$389,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Natalie Baldwin
Welcome to your Buckeye Lake retreat! Built in 2025, this beautifully crafted home offers the perfect blend of modern comfort, timeless finishes, and an unbeatable location in the heart of Millersport. The open-concept floor plan is filled with natural light and showcases soaring vaulted ceilings, rich hardwood flooring, a cozy fireplace, and designer finishes throughout. The spacious kitchen features quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, abundant cabinetry, and a large island that's perfect for gathering with family and friends. On first floor you will find a spacious owners retreat, along with four generously sized bedrooms on second floor. The fourth bedroom upstairs can dual as sleeping space or flex space if needed. With thoughtfully designed living spaces, there's plenty of room to relax, entertain, or host overnight guests and the outdoor patio provides the perfect spot to unwind after a day on the lake. Located just a short walk or golf cart ride from Buckeye Lake, the marina and docks, waterfront restaurants, shopping, and local favorites, you'll enjoy easy access to boating, fishing, festivals, and year-round entertainment. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or an investment property, this home offers exceptional flexibility. Short-term rentals are permitted, making it an excellent opportunity for those looking to generate income when not enjoying it themselves. Move-in ready and option for a fully furnished home, this is your opportunity to start enjoying the Buckeye Lake lifestyle from day one.

12073 Ninth Avenue, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Natalie Baldwin ---- Red 1 Realty
3986 N Bank Road NE, Millersport
$280,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Barbara Russell
Charming Buckeye Lake Cottage on a Double Lot ! Front Entrance is located on N Bank with a back entrance from Avalon. A standout feature is the detached garage, complete with a deck that has been converted to a gym with a full bath and cozy loft with plenty of storage space AND it is situated on its own lot! This versatile space would make an adorable guest house, studio or private retreat. Or it could easily be converted to a garage to suit your needs. Both the home and outbuilding feature new metal roofs and siding in 2025! This adorable cottage offers the perfect blend of character, flexibility, and lake-area living situated across the street from the water! The main home features 3 bedrooms, including a convenient first-floor owner's suite, cozy living room featuring a gas fireplace and the renovated kitchen offers a great place to gather. Wide-plank LVT flooring runs throughout the main floor, adding a fresh, modern touch. The second floor features a bedroom and spacious sitting area. Step outside to the new deck and patio overlooking the fenced back yard, ideal for entertaining, relaxing with your morning coffee or enjoying a summer evening at the lake. With its charming cottage feel, double-lot setting, versatile outbuilding, shed for storage and location just across the street from the water, this property offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy all that lake living has to offer ! Or use as a VRBO rental ! Please include both parcels when writing an offer!

3986 N Bank Road NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Barbara Russell ---- RE/MAX ONE
9730 Lake Road NE, Millersport
$349,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Jason L Gunsorek
Huge 2200 sf property with 4 car garage and and .50 acre lot! This home has big room additions, a gorgeous master bath with walk-in closet and large vanity, and a carpeted basement for many uses. All windows have been replaced with a transferable warranty. New siding throughout and the four car garage was connected and renovated into one seamless unit. Additionally a fifth garage was added for additional storage. Only about 35 minutes to Columbus/ 10 mins from Buckeye Lake and it's rural enough to give you privacy as you can see from photos. The house is move in ready.

9730 Lake Road NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Jason L Gunsorek ---- Real Estate Opportunity
11736 Broad Street, Millersport
$289,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Adam M Leith
Welcome to 11736 Broad St. in Millersport. Sitting on nearly ½ acre with single floor living this quiet street just off the main road is blocks from buckeye lake, the sweetcorn festival, elementary school and many iconic attractions such as Weldons icecream. 1650+ sq. ft, 3 br, 2.5 ba, attached garage. Gas fireplace, Full Bath just off the primary bedroom complete with Jacuzzi tub, dual-sink vanity, and large walk-in shower. Just off the living room is the three-season room with access to the back yard. Just driving by the front porch invites you to come sit and enjoy. All Kitchen appliances stay including the new dishwasher installed 9/2026. New central Heating and A/C installed 2022. New garage door and opener.

11736 Broad Street, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Adam M Leith ---- Leith Realty LLC
Newark Drive NE, Millersport
$150,000
⋅ Renee S Sweatland
Build your dream home on this desirable buildable lot near Sellers Point at beautiful Buckeye Lake! Gas, electric, and water are available, making it an ideal location for your future home or weekend getaway. Water at North Bank. Enjoy a short walk to the lake and the scenic boardwalk, where you can take in the waterfront views, dining, and recreation. The public boat launch is just minutes away, providing easy access to boating, fishing, and all the fun Buckeye Lake has to offer. Don't miss this opportunity to own a great lot in one of the area's most sought-after lake communities!

Newark Drive NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Renee S Sweatland ---- Move Real Estate
13673 Cherry Lane, Millersport
$300,000
⋅ Makayla Friedman
Discover the opportunity to own 5 beautiful acres in one of Central Ohio's fastest-growing recreational areas. Ideally situated less than 3 miles from Buckeye Lake and another premier lake destination in the Mid-Eastern region, this property offers the perfect combination of privacy, convenience, and long-term potential. A large section of the wooded acreage has already been cleared, creating an ideal private homesite for your dream home, vacation retreat, or future investment. Property highlights include: • Private build site with a significant portion of the woods already cleared • Less than 3 miles from Buckeye Lake • 2.6 miles to I-70 • 2.6 miles to Flying J Travel Center • 4.8 miles to Buckeye Lake Marina • 9.7 miles to the future Meijer Supercenter • 11 miles to Legend Valley • 11 miles to Buckeye Lake Winery Exciting plans are underway to transform the Buckeye Lake region into a premier year-round destination for visitors from Central Ohio and beyond. With continued investment and development throughout the area, this property is positioned to benefit from the region's growing appeal and tourism. See the attached documents for additional information on the area's development plans and envision the possibilities that await. Whether you're looking to build your forever home or invest in a thriving destination, this property offers endless potential.

13673 Cherry Lane, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Makayla Friedman ---- Di Lusso Real Estate
13515 Newark Drive NE, Millersport
$65,000
⋅ Roberta Lepi
Close to Buckeye Lake! Low traffic location! Great potential!

13515 Newark Drive NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Roberta Lepi ---- LEPI & ASSOC.

Avalon Drive NE, Millersport
$150,000
⋅ Scott A Marvin
Discover an exceptional opportunity to own four parcels totaling nearly half an acre, nestled in a serene, wooded setting. This expansive lot offers the perfect canvas to build your dream lake house, surrounded by mature trees and natural beauty. Enjoy privacy, plenty of space for outdoor living, and the flexibility to design a custom retreat tailored to your lifestyle. Whether you envision a cozy cottage or a spacious family getaway, this property provides endless possibilities for Buckeye Lake living.

Avalon Drive NE, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : Scott A Marvin ---- Team Results Realty
11890 Broad Street, Millersport
$305,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ John Kohlhepp
Spacious Opportunity Near Buckeye Lake! Welcome to 11890 Broad Street in the heart of Millersport—an expansive 6-bedroom, 4.5-bath home offering incredible potential just minutes from Buckeye Lake. This large residence has had work started and is ready for a new owner to finish and customize to their vision. With its generous layout and bedroom count, this property is ideal for a vacation home, or large family retreat. Conveniently located right off the main road, you'll enjoy easy access to local restaurants, a nearby coffee shop, and all the charm Millersport has to offer—plus quick access to Buckeye Lake for boating, dining, and year-round recreation. Whether you're an investor or someone looking to create a one-of-a-kind lake-area getaway, this property presents a rare opportunity to add value in a highly desirable location.

11890 Broad Street, Millersport

Listing Courtesy of : John Kohlhepp ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!