Bellefontaine Homes under $500,000

Bellefontaine Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Bellefontaine, Ohio – a charming city that perfectly blends small-town warmth with modern conveniences. Nestled in the heart of Logan County, Bellefontaine is renowned for its rich history, stunning landscapes, and a tight-knit community that welcomes newcomers with open arms. With its picturesque parks, vibrant downtown area, and a variety of local shops and restaurants, Bellefontaine offers a delightful lifestyle for families, retirees, and everyone in between.

One of the most appealing aspects of Bellefontaine is its affordable housing market. For those seeking their dream home without breaking the bank, you'll find a wonderful selection of homes available for under $500,000. From cozy bungalows to spacious family homes, the real estate options here cater to a diverse range of tastes and budgets. Many properties boast charming architectural details, modern updates, and beautiful outdoor spaces, making it easy to find a place that feels like home.

The city is also home to excellent schools, a thriving arts scene, and plenty of recreational opportunities, including nearby hiking trails and lakes for outdoor enthusiasts. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat or an active lifestyle, Bellefontaine has it all.

With a strong sense of community and an array of affordable housing options, Bellefontaine is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Come explore this hidden gem in Ohio and discover why so many are choosing to call Bellefontaine home!

Newest Bellefontaine Homes under $500,000

213 Meadowbrook Drive, Bellefontaine
$264,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Bryn L Daring-Stewart
Immaculate brick ranch situated on a quiet dead-end street! This well-maintained, updated home features 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, a formal living room, and a spacious family room with a wood-burning fireplace. The eat-in kitchen offers updated cabinets, countertops, sink, and stove. Enjoy the outdoors from the 20' x 12' deck overlooking the fenced backyard and creek. The approximately 85' x 165' lot offers .32 acres of space to enjoy. Additional features include a laundry room, attached 2-car garage, off-street parking, and a large storage shed that stays. New roof, gutters, guards and soffit in 2025; Entire HVAC in 2021. Additional updates include the baths (half bath updated in 2026), hardwood flooring, solid wood trim, and door. Don't miss your opportunity to see this beautiful home--call today to schedule your private showing!

213 Meadowbrook Drive, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Bryn L Daring-Stewart ---- ROYER REALTY LLC
County Road 290 Lot DD Unit Lot DD, Bellefontaine
$109,900
⋅ Bryn L Daring-Stewart
Located along U.S. 68 and County Road 290 in Lake Township, within the Indian Lake School District, is this set of rural building lots being surveyed out of a larger parcel. There are four options ranging from 1.35 acres to 2.531 acres. Each lot varies in price, size and road frontage. Acreage - AA: 1.353 ac, B B: 2.146 ac, CC: 2.531 ac, DD: 2.398 ac. Deed restrictions apply (minimum 1800sqft home, no manufactured/mobile homes, and others; restrictions in MLS). For Lake Twp Zoning information, contact the local zoning inspector or the LUC Regional Planning. Call today for your appointment to check out this land!

County Road 290 Lot DD Unit Lot DD, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Bryn L Daring-Stewart ---- ROYER REALTY LLC
County Road 290 Lot CC Unit Lot CC, Bellefontaine
$109,900
⋅ Bryn L Daring-Stewart
Located along U.S. 68 and County Road 290 in Lake Township, within the Indian Lake School District, is this set of rural building lots being surveyed out of a larger parcel. There are four options ranging from 1.35 acres to 2.531 acres. Each lot varies in price, size and road frontage. Acreage - AA: 1.353 ac, B B: 2.146 ac, CC: 2.531 ac, DD: 2.398 ac. Deed restrictions apply (minimum 1800sqft home, no manufactured/mobile homes, and others; restrictions in MLS). For Lake Twp Zoning information, contact the local zoning inspector or the LUC Regional Planning. Call today for your appointment to check out this land!

County Road 290 Lot CC Unit Lot CC, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Bryn L Daring-Stewart ---- ROYER REALTY LLC
County Road 290 Lot BB Unit Lot BB, Bellefontaine
$99,900
⋅ Bryn L Daring-Stewart
Located along U.S. 68 and County Road 290 in Lake Township, within the Indian Lake School District, is this set of rural building lots being surveyed out of a larger parcel. There are four options ranging from 1.35 acres to 2.531 acres. Each lot varies in price, size and road frontage. Acreage - AA: 1.353 ac, B B: 2.146 ac, CC: 2.531 ac, DD: 2.398 ac. Deed restrictions apply (minimum 1800sqft home, no manufactured/mobile homes, and others; restrictions in MLS). For Lake Twp Zoning information, contact the local zoning inspector or the LUC Regional Planning. Call today for your appointment to check out this land!

County Road 290 Lot BB Unit Lot BB, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Bryn L Daring-Stewart ---- ROYER REALTY LLC
County Road 290 Lot AA Unit Lot AA, Bellefontaine
$79,900
⋅ Bryn L Daring-Stewart
Located along U.S. 68 and County Road 290 in Lake Township, within the Indian Lake School District, is this set of rural building lots being surveyed out of a larger parcel. There are four options ranging from 1.35 acres to 2.531 acres. Each lot varies in price, size and road frontage. Acreage - AA: 1.353 ac, B B: 2.146 ac, CC: 2.531 ac, DD: 2.398 ac. Deed restrictions apply (minimum 1800sqft home, no manufactured/mobile homes, and others; restrictions in MLS). For Lake Twp Zoning information, contact the local zoning inspector or the LUC Regional Planning. Call today for your appointment to check out this land!

County Road 290 Lot AA Unit Lot AA, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Bryn L Daring-Stewart ---- ROYER REALTY LLC
1836 County Road 11, Bellefontaine
$349,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Bryn L Daring-Stewart
Well-maintained tri-level home conveniently located just outside of Bellefontaine! Offering 1,696 sq. ft. of living space, this home features 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a walk-out basement. The mid-level includes a living room, dining area, and kitchen, while the upper level offers three bedrooms and a full bath. The lower level features a cozy family room with a fireplace, additional flex space, laundry area, and a second full bath. Appliances include a dishwasher (new in 2024), refrigerator (new in 2026), range, washer, dryer, and water softener (replaced in 2021). The propane tank is owned. Enjoy the outdoors with low-maintenance landscaping, a welcoming front porch, and two rear patios, including one covered patio. Recent improvements include a second driveway leading to a gravel pad, providing an ideal site for a future outbuilding. Situated on a spacious 0.96-acre lot measuring approximately 140' x 270', this property offers room to enjoy both indoor and outdoor living. Call today to schedule your private showing!

1836 County Road 11, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Bryn L Daring-Stewart ---- ROYER REALTY LLC
101 S Heather Hill Dr Drive, Bellefontaine
$364,500
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Jessica Mcneil
If you are looking for a spacious, updated ranch home in a secluded neighborhood with quick access to the highway, all while being minutes away from downtown Bellefontaine, this is the house for you! This home offers over 2,000 SqFt of living space with 4 bedrooms, an entry level laundry room and 3 full bathrooms! The sunken living room creates an inviting and dedicated space to relax or enjoy company. But that isn't the only place to enjoy company, take a walk outside and you will find a large, deck opening up to the fenced in backyard of this corner lot. There is so much about this house to love, including the updated flooring, the Master bathroom's freestanding tub and tile shower, the Jack-and-Jill bathroom on the additional bedrooms, the large windows throughout, the bright kitchen that opens up to the dining room, additional finished space in the basement and so much more! Beyond the obvious beauty of the home, there are some updates to note: Roof (2023), Dishwasher (2024), Water Softener (2025), Garage door Opener (2025), Fresh paint on deck & porch (2025) and crawlspace encapsulation (2025). Don't let this one slip through your fingers!

101 S Heather Hill Dr Drive, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Jessica Mcneil ---- Red 1 Realty
140 N Stanley Street, Bellefontaine
$227,000
⋅ Malia K Hughes
Expand your investment portfolio with this income-producing, two-unit property at 140 N Stanley Street in Bellefontaine! Conveniently located near downtown, shopping, and eateries, with easy highway access, this multi-family property offers spacious layouts and separately metered utilities. The first-floor unit features 2 bedrooms, an oversized kitchen, a laundry room with washer/dryer hookups, central heat and air conditioning, and covered front and rear porches. The upper unit offers 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and generous living, dining, and kitchen areas, with electric heat throughout. Off-street parking at the rear adds convenience. The upstairs unit is currently vacant and ready for a new tenant, offering an opportunity to establish your own rental terms. All utilities are separate. Whether adding to your rental portfolio or exploring your first investment property, this duplex deserves a look. Call today to schedule your private tour!

140 N Stanley Street, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Malia K Hughes ---- Key Realty
104 Willows End, Bellefontaine
$449,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Joseph J Evans
RANCH + TAX ABATEMENT; RANCH+ HECM APPROVED; RANCH + CUSTOM DESIGNS; RANCH + NO MOWING + NO SHOVELING SNOW! If you are looking for a RANCH with high end CUSTOM finishes, an over-sized TWO car garage and a TAX ABATEMENT and a subdivision that is HECM approved .... this is YOUR RANCH HOME!! Custom finishes include custom designed, soft close cabinets and doors; granite kitchen island and perimeter; granite bathroom counter tops, custom lighting, ceiling fans, television and cable outlets, covered outdoor living space, spacious laundry room and much more. Visit and you'll agree...this is a true rare gem proudly located in Bellefontaine!

104 Willows End, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Joseph J Evans ---- RE/MAX Town Center
416 Woodside Place, Bellefontaine
$240,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Dava D Royer
Autumn Woods Condo! This condo consists of 1156 sqft with a great room, sunroom, kitchen, two full baths and two bedrooms! The sunroom overlooks the inner circle and has heating/cooling for year-round enjoyment. The condo is built on a slab and has a two-car attached garage. Updates include: HVAC and Water Softener 2018. The condo fee is $150/month and covers spring mulching, mowing, snow removal and front flower bed landscaping. Call today!

416 Woodside Place, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Dava D Royer ---- ROYER REALTY LLC
548 Center Avenue, Bellefontaine
$224,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Bryn L Daring-Stewart
This charming two-story property features approximately 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath, with a versatile layout and a convenient location just minutes from State Route 33. The main floor features a welcoming front room with an open feel leading into the original dining area, a kitchen, laundry area, and a large main-floor bedroom. The second floor offers two additional bedrooms, including a loft-style room with a closet and another private bedroom with its own door and closet. Original character can be found throughout the home, including the covered front porch with classic columns and the home's historic proportions and details. The property also includes a cool, old-fashioned cellar with stone and concrete elements that reflect the age and history of the home. The property is B-1 zoned with an interesting opportunity for an entrepreneur, home-office user, professional, or buyer looking for a property with flexibility and visibility. Situated on a corner lot with room for parking and easy access to State Route 33, this property has a unique combination of historic character, practical space, and potential for the next owner to make it their own.

548 Center Avenue, Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : Bryn L Daring-Stewart ---- ROYER REALTY LLC
Bellefontaine
$219,900
⋅ V. Patrick Hamilton
Offering three separate residential units in one convenient Bellefontaine location, 645 N Main Street presents a strong opportunity for an investor looking for established rental income and a versatile unit mix. The property includes 645 N Main, featuring 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath; 645 1/2 N Main, offering 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath; and 643 N Main, featuring 1 bedroom and 1 full bath. With approximately 2,768 square feet of total living area, the property provides three distinct rental units under one ownership. The gross monthly rent is $1,900.00 and each tenant is responsible for their own utilities, helping simplify operating expenses for the property owner. Existing leases provide immediate rental income, while the mix of one-, two-, and three-bedroom units offer flexibility for continued rental use. Situated on approximately 0.27 acres along N Main Street, the property is also conveniently located near revitalized downtown Bellefontaine, giving tenants easy access to local restaurants, shops, entertainment, community events, and other downtown amenities while still enjoying a residential setting. Whether you're an experienced investor looking to add another income-producing property to your portfolio or someone just getting started in real estate investing, 645 N Main Street offers an approachable opportunity with three separate rental units, an established income stream, and a convenient location near downtown Bellefontaine.

Bellefontaine

Listing Courtesy of : V. Patrick Hamilton ---- REMAX Alliance Realty
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!