New Plymouth Homes for Sale

New Plymouth Homes for Sale

Welcome to New Plymouth, Ohio—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Appalachian region. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, New Plymouth offers a unique blend of small-town charm and modern amenities. With a population of just over 1,000 residents, this cozy village is the perfect place to escape the hustle and bustle of city life while still enjoying the conveniences of nearby urban centers.

New Plymouth boasts a rich history and a vibrant local culture, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a close-knit community. The area is surrounded by stunning natural beauty, including rolling hills, lush forests, and sparkling streams, perfect for outdoor enthusiasts. Whether you enjoy hiking, fishing, or simply taking in the breathtaking scenery, New Plymouth has something for everyone.

When it comes to real estate, New Plymouth offers a variety of homes for sale, catering to diverse tastes and budgets. From charming historic houses that exude character to modern builds with all the latest amenities, you’re sure to find the perfect place to call home. The local real estate market is thriving, providing excellent opportunities for first-time buyers and seasoned investors alike.

With its welcoming atmosphere, affordable housing options, and abundant recreational activities, New Plymouth is not just a place to live—it’s a place to thrive. Explore the homes for sale today and discover why so many are choosing to make New Plymouth their forever home. Your dream home awaits in this idyllic Ohio village!

Newest New Plymouth Homes for Sale

$975,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Joan Elflein
Own a remarkable piece of Vinton County history in the Hocking Hills area. The Shurtz Family Farm offers a rare opportunity to enjoy historic character, modern updates, and 12.5 peaceful acres in one of southeastern Ohio's most sought after regions. Thoughtfully restored, this late 19th century sandstone home offers 2,025 SF, 2 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, blending timeless character with comfortable everyday living. Beyond the home, the property invites you to imagine the possibilities. A garden leads to a beautifully decorated detached family room, connected to the farm's original corn crib, now transformed into a screened sitting area with rocking chairs-an unforgettable place for quiet mornings and peaceful evenings. The insulated one car detached garage offers potential for a workshop, studio, hobby space or a buyer's own vision. A charming potting shed, open fields and rolling countryside add to the property's sense of space and tranquility. Near the water, a peaceful pond with a private dock creates another destination to enjoy. An unfinished cabin overlooking the pond, complete with electric and water hookups, offers exciting potential as additional living space, a guest retreat, creative space or something entirely your own. Adding to the property's remarkable history is a rare 2 story octagonal barn built in 1885, complete with electricity and ready for its next chapter. Water source is spring fed cistern. Thoughtful improvements, including a new Standing Seam Metal Roof and new insulated windows. Updated electrical, plumbing, and HVAC, provide modern functionality while preserving the property's historic appeal. This exceptional property offers proximity to renowned natural beauty and outdoor recreation while feeling like a peaceful retreat all its own. Whether envisioned as a full time residence, weekend escape, family gathering place, hobby farm, or creative retreat, the possibilities are as distinctive as the property itself. Sold fully furnished.

24754 Shurtz Road, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Joan Elflein ---- Ohio Broker Direct, LLC
$1,350,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Kenneth Spangler
Tucked into the Hocking Hills and bordered on three sides by Wayne National Forest, this private retreat offers true seclusion just minutes from Ash Cave, Cedar Falls, and Old Man's Cave. The 3,360 sq ft home features 4 bedrooms and 3 baths, can sleep up to 15 people. Is ideal as a personal getaway or income-producing lodging business. Enjoy an in-ground pool, hot tub, theater room, and game room -- perfect for hosting groups. With acreage to spare for future building sites, this is a rare opportunity to own a slice of Hocking Hills wilderness with proven rental history. Nature, privacy, and income potential -- all in one unforgettable setting.

37775 Coonville Road, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Kenneth Spangler ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
$1,495,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Elizabeth K Heil
Rare opportunity to acquire a four-cabin short-term rental portfolio in the heart of the Hocking Hills region. The offering includes four individual 1-bedroom, 1-bath cabins to be conveyed on an approximately 5± acre parcel, with final acreage and parcel boundaries to be determined by survey and subject to all applicable approvals. Each cabin offers a private screened-in rear porch with hot tub, allowing guests to enjoy the peaceful wooded setting in virtually any weather. Each cabin is served by its own septic system. Each cabin has a PTAC unit that is electric and provides heating and air conditioning. Each of the cabins has a propane tank for the fireplace on a thermostat. The owners said there is no need to worry about a power outage and frozen pipes! 1 starlink account services all 4 cabins. Located approximately 9 miles from Ash Cave and convenient to the many attractions, trails, dining, and recreation that draw visitors to Hocking Hills year-round. The property is also near the site of the planned Hocking Hills mountain coaster, anticipated to debut in spring 2027 and expected to be the first attraction of its kind in Ohio. An excellent opportunity for an investor seeking an established four-unit hospitality property in one of Ohio's premier tourism destinations. Property is being split from a larger parcel; final legal description, acreage, parcel configuration, easements and access, if applicable, to be determined upon completion of survey.

28170 State Route 93, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Elizabeth K Heil ---- RE/MAX Achievers
$899,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Meredith W Tomlinson
Turnkey Hocking Hills investment opportunity producing 125K in annual revenue! Whether you're expanding your short-term rental portfolio or diving into the STR business for the first time, this property delivers. Set in the heart of Hocking Hills, a destination that draws visitors year-round, this 5-bedroom, 3-full-bath home sits on 11 private acres and sleeps up to 20 guests comfortably. Just minutes from the area's top attractions, yet guests won't want to leave. A private pool, expansive wraparound deck, and generous gathering spaces make it perfect for unforgettable group getaways, with nearly 10 acres offering room to explore and room to grow. Think cabins, glamping sites, or additional guest amenities down the road. Offered as a fully turnkey business, this is a step-in-and-start-earning opportunity: a proven destination property, an established income stream, and serious upside potential. Your chance to own a piece of Hocking Hills and a business that's already working for you.

20328 St Rt 328, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Meredith W Tomlinson ---- EXP Realty, LLC
$1,654,999
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Jake Ryan
Two Brand New Luxury Cabins on 42 Acres Two brand new luxury cabins on 42 rolling acres in Hocking Hills, just completed and coming online for rental right now. This is a rare chance to step into a turnkey short term rental investment with the newest product on the market and real room to grow. The three bedroom and the two bedroom share the same open, modern floor plan: soaring ceilings, walls of glass, and wide open living spaces designed for groups. The only difference is the lower level, where the larger cabin picks up an additional bedroom. Both were finished to the same standard throughout, with everything brand new from the foundation up. Near the front of the property sits a brand new detached garage, finished to the same high standard as the cabins. Inside is a one bedroom apartment already framed in and ready to be completed as a third rentable unit, owner's quarters, or on site staff housing. The land is the other half of the story. 42 acres of beautiful rolling hills, privacy in every direction, and plenty of usable ground for additional builds. All improvements carry full state approval, so the groundwork for expansion is already done. Whether you want a cash flowing asset with zero deferred maintenance or the foundation for your own boutique resort, this property delivers both: income from day one and the runway to scale.

20350 Ohio 328, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Jake Ryan ---- Rock House Realty LLC
$649,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Valerie L Freda
Escape to your own private retreat with this beautiful Stonemill log and timber home nestled on 10 scenic wooded acres. Located just minutes from Ash Cave and approximately 25 minutes from Ohio University, this property offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths, hickory hardwood floors, clawfoot tub, stone wood-burning fireplace, and finished lower-level entertainment space. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, weekend getaway, or vacation rental opportunity, this unique property offers privacy, character, and an unbeatable natural setting.

65054 State Route 56, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Valerie L Freda ---- Associates Realty
$399,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Holly Dozer
Your Hocking Hills Escape Awaits! Are you looking for short term rental or primary home in Hocking Hills that checks all the boxes? Privacy! The ability to expand! and fantastic rental projections! This home also qualifies for a USDA loan if purchased as a home! Imagine waking up surrounded by 6+ private acres of peaceful woods, sipping coffee on the covered porch, then ending the day around the fire pit under a sky full of stars. This beautifully renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bath cabin is move-in ready and perfectly positioned as a short-term rental, weekend getaway, or full-time retreat. Features you'll love: 6+ wooded acres of privacy and and additional 3.7 acres if desired! 2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms Stunning chef-inspired kitchen with butcher block countertops Farmhouse sink & open-concept living Outdoor fire pit for unforgettable evenings Easy access with plenty of parking Just minutes from the best hiking, waterfalls, wineries, and adventures Hocking Hills has to offer! Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio or finally own the home/cabin you've always dreamed of, this one checks all the boxes. Hurry before someone else claims this slice of Hocking Hills paradise!

19431 State Route 328, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Holly Dozer ---- Rock House Realty LLC
$639,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Jake Ryan
Tucked away at the end of the road on 18 wooded acres, the Boondocks Bungalow is the kind of place where the loudest thing you'll hear is the bullfrogs singing on the pond. This 4-bedroom, 2-bath cottage sleeps 10 comfortably, making it perfect for family getaways, friend reunions, or a quiet couples' retreat with room to spread out. Inside, you'll find an open-concept living space warmed by handmade reclaimed-wood accents, a fully equipped kitchen, and cozy spots to gather after a day of exploring. High-speed internet means you can stream a movie or sneak in a little remote work -- but we won't blame you if you never open the laptop. The real magic is outside. Soak in the hot tub under the trees, cast a line off the dock into the half-acre stocked pond, or wander the private forest trails where owls, foxes, and whitetail deer make regular appearances. When evening rolls in, gather around the open-air fire pit in the meadow for s'mores and some of the best stargazing in Hocking Hills. A covered porch with a swing, back deck, and stone patio give you plenty of places to slow down with a morning coffee. Just a short drive from Old Man's Cave, Ash Cave, and everything the Hocking Hills has to offer -- but far enough out that it feels like it's all yours.

20641 Trowbridge Road, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Jake Ryan ---- Rock House Realty LLC
$89,000
⋅ Sarah Claypool
Discover the potential of this beautiful 4.5-acre parcel in scenic Vinton County. With the driveway already completed, this property is ready for you to begin bringing your vision to life. Whether you're planning to build your dream home, a private weekend retreat, or a short-term rental investment, the possibilities are endless. Enjoy peaceful surroundings, beautiful views, and the privacy that comes with country living, all while being within easy reach of the Hocking Hills region and southeastern Ohio's abundant outdoor recreation. If you've been searching for the perfect setting to build, this property is one you won't want to miss.

66505 Airport Road, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Sarah Claypool ---- Rock House Realty LLC
$1,449,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Jody M Jubach
Experience luxury cabin living in Hocking Hills with this stunning to-be-built custom log home, thoughtfully designed for legacy ownership, executive retreats, or upscale vacation living. Privately nestled along a secluded road surrounded by mature woods, rolling terrain, and picturesque ravines, this exceptional homesite is positioned back from the road and accessed by a long, flat driveway - offering a rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and convenient accessibility. Designed for both comfort and entertaining, this thoughtfully crafted 3-bedroom, 3.5-bath home features an expansive open-concept layout across both the main and lower levels, as well as a lofted upper floor. The main living area centers around a breathtaking double-sided handcrafted stone fireplace, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. Custom cabinetry, tile showers, and real wood flooring are just some of the finishes still available for the buyer to choose to truly make it your own. Outdoor living is equally impressive with expansive 3-sided covered porch decking on the main level, highlighted by a dramatic 15-foot gable-end porch ideal for enjoying the peaceful wooded surroundings. The lower level adds even more entertaining space with covered decking on two sides. Located near the breathtaking parks, waterfalls, hiking trails, caves, and outdoor recreation that make Hocking Hills one of the Midwest's premier vacation destinations, this property offers endless opportunities for adventure, relaxation, and investment potential. Exterior and interior photos represent similar finishes from this premier log home builder's gallery.

21844 Frantz Road, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Jody M Jubach ---- Key Realty
$759,000
⋅ Scott T Hill
Adjoining 27,822 acres of Zaleski State Forest in the heart of the Hocking Hills region, this 68.892-acre wooded property offers a rare opportunity to own a large recreational tract in one of Southern Ohio's most desirable outdoor destinations. Just minutes from Lake Hope State Park, this property is ideally situated near one of the region's most popular parks and lakes, enhancing its appeal for recreation and tourism. Featuring rolling terrain, abundant wildlife, and the excellent hunting the area is known for, this tract is ideal for outdoor enthusiasts, hunters, investors, developers, or cabin builders seeking a premier location. A creek meanders through the property, adding natural beauty, wildlife attractions, and a valuable water feature for recreational use or future cabin development. Marketable timber possibilities provide additional upside, while the scenic setting, privacy, and proximity to extensive public lands make it perfect for cabin rental sites, vacation cabins, or a private getaway retreat. Improvements include a 30x60 pole barn built in 2007 with a concrete floor, offering excellent storage for equipment, ATVs, or a hunting camp setup. A new survey has been completed, providing clearly defined boundaries and added confidence for future use or development. With direct access to thousands of acres of state forest land, this property delivers exceptional hunting, hiking, and recreational opportunities in a highly sought-after Hocking Hills region location.

70518 Two Mile Road, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : Scott T Hill ---- Hill Real Estate
$1,225,000
6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ AMANDA MYERS
Tucked away in the heart of the Hocking Hills, this exceptional property at 66245 Old Shurtz Road offers a rare opportunity to own a turnkey retreat with incredible income and unforgettable views. Set on a scenic parcel surrounded by nature, the property features two thoughtfully designed and newer-built accommodations. The main cabin boasts 4 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, blending rustic charm with modern comfort. Warm wood finishes, inviting living spaces, and expansive windows showcase the stunning natural surroundings, creating the perfect setting for relaxing getaways. Complementing the cabin is a stylish 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom tiny container home--an increasingly popular and highly desirable short-term rental option. With efficient design, modern amenities, and its own private vantage point, it offers guests a unique and memorable stay. Both units are ideally positioned to capture breathtaking views and provide a peaceful, private experience, all while being just minutes from the area's most popular attractions, hiking trails, parks, restaurants, and shops. Currently operating with strong rental income, this property is a proven performer with even more upside. With ample space and favorable layout, there is potential to expand and add additional rental units, making this an outstanding investment opportunity or a personal retreat with income-producing capability. Whether you're looking to grow your short-term rental portfolio or own your own slice of Hocking Hills paradise, this one-of-a-kind property delivers on location, versatility, and long-term potential.

66245 Old Shurtz Road, New Plymouth

Listing Courtesy of : AMANDA MYERS ---- Rock House Realty LLC
Start Your Search