Bexley Real Estate

Bexley Real Estate

Welcome to Bexley, Ohio – a charming suburban gem nestled in Franklin County, just a stone's throw from the bustling heart of Columbus. Known for its picturesque tree-lined streets, historic architecture, and vibrant community spirit, Bexley offers an ideal blend of small-town charm and urban convenience.

Founded in the early 1900s, Bexley has a rich history that is reflected in its beautiful homes and well-preserved neighborhoods. The city boasts a variety of architectural styles, from classic Colonials to modern builds, making it a delightful place for homebuyers of all tastes. The community is renowned for its excellent schools, including Bexley High School, which consistently ranks among the top in the state, making it a perfect choice for families.

Bexley is not just about residential charm; it also features a thriving local economy with unique shops, delightful cafes, and a variety of dining options that cater to every palate. The city is home to the prestigious Capital University, adding a youthful energy and cultural vibrancy to the area. Residents enjoy easy access to parks and recreational facilities, including the beautiful Jeffrey Park, perfect for picnics, jogging, or simply unwinding in nature.

With its strong sense of community, rich history, and convenient location, Bexley, Ohio, is a wonderful place to call home. Whether you're looking for a quaint bungalow or a spacious family residence, this city has something to offer everyone. Come experience the warmth and charm of Bexley – your new home awaits!

Newest Listings in Bexley

2620 E Broad Street, Bexley
$929,900
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Amy E Conley
With story-book charm this French Normandy-inspired residence is surrounded by beautifully curated gardens and exquisite landscaping. The carriage house, complete with window boxes, adds to the property's timeless character. (NOTE: Main house has 3 bedrooms, Carriage house has 2 bedrooms). The renovated main residence offers spacious living and dining rooms, while the inviting family room features a gas-log fireplace and beautiful wood-beamed ceiling. The center-island kitchen offers a casual eat-in area and sliding doors that open to a well appointed backyard. The spacious primary suite offers an oversized bath with a soaking tub, separate vanities, and a private water closet.Adding exceptional versatility, the charming carriage house offers a kitchenette and a full bath--ideal for guests or a private work-from-home retreat.Don't overlook the additional 264 square feet of private, enclosed storage space in the garage. With its privacy and flexibility, it's an ideal opportunity for a home gym, hobby space, or creative retreat. Updates: New Anderson windows 2024, Added Sump Pump 2020, Roof Replaced 2012, Carriage House Roof 2018, New Water Heater 2022, Remodeled Master Bath 2022, Remodeled kitchen 2014

2620 E Broad Street, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Amy E Conley ---- Cutler Real Estate
857 Sheridan Avenue, Bexley
$369,000
⋅ Jay R Zollars
Currently downstairs unit vacant. Owner just remodeled both bathrooms 2026. New concrete in 2024. Driveway new blacktop done in 2021, Hardwood floors throughout. New windows in 2018, Located across the street from Capital University. 2nd Floor rent ed for $1350/month. Owner Agent

857 Sheridan Avenue, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Jay R Zollars ---- RZ Realty
336 S Columbia Avenue, Bexley
$2,800,000
6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ Amy E Conley
Sensational home on one of Bexley's most prestigious streets, with a pool and separate Carriage house apartment. Soaring ceilings and walls of windows in this Italian Renaissance Architecture home create a spacious, relaxing atmosphere. The entry level is an entertainers dream with a cozy hearth room that opens into a massive sunken living room with wet bar and a piano/game area. Lounge in the unique sunroom with floating couch swings, or step out onto the patio and walk to the 40' x 16' heated saltwater pool. Kitchen is a dream with large island, Jenn-Air appliances, built-in banquette, and walk-in pantry. Upstairs the Primary Suite Wing is an oasis. Relax in the spa room with a soaking tub and sauna room. Massive Primary bedroom with additional sitting room and private balcony. The primary bathroom offers a second soaking tub and glass shower. 3 additional bedrooms on this level, plus a bonus room and bedroom above the garage. Media Room in the lower level.

336 S Columbia Avenue, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Amy E Conley ---- Cutler Real Estate
236 N Roosevelt Avenue, Bexley
$639,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Rachel M Alley
Welcome to Bexley! This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath Cape Cod offers a floor plan designed for connection, comfort, and everyday convenience. A standout feature is the first-floor primary suite, offering the ease of main-level living without sacrificing space for family or guests. At the heart of the home, the open-concept kitchen, dining, and family room create a natural gathering place for everything from busy weekday mornings to weekend entertaining. The seamless flow between these spaces makes it easy to stay connected. Upstairs, two additional bedrooms and a full bathroom provide flexibility for guests, home offices, or growing needs. The finished lower-level recreation room adds another versatile space for movie nights, hobbies, or entertaining. Outdoor living is equally inviting! Start your morning with coffee on the newly added front porch (2026), enjoy evenings on the screened-in back porch, or spend time in the backyard. These spaces extend the living experience outdoors and offer multiple places to relax, gather, and unwind. Significant improvements provide added peace of mind, including a new HVAC system and thermostat (2026), roof (2022), second-floor blown-in insulation (2021), and a new garage door and concrete floor (2024). The detached two-car garage also features a Tesla charging station. Located in the established Bexley community near local parks, dining, shopping, and the amenities of Columbus, this home offers a rare combination of a first-floor primary suite, open living spaces, multiple outdoor gathering areas, and meaningful updates. Experience the lifestyle and convenience of living in Bexley!

236 N Roosevelt Avenue, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Rachel M Alley ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs
903 Chelsea Avenue, Bexley
$377,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Michael D Carruthers
Highly Desirable S. Bexley Cape Cod - 3 Bedrooms - 2 Full Baths - 1,166 Square Feet - Living Room with Wood Burning Fireplace Open to Dining Room - Hardwood Floors - 2 Bedrooms & 1 Full Bath on 1st Floor - Large 2nd Floor Primary Bedroom with 2nd Full Bath - New Kitchen 2024 with White Shaker Cabinetry, Granite Countertops & Gray Subway Tile Backsplash - New & Updated Bathrooms 2024 - Freshly Painted Interior 2026 - Full Unfinished Open Basement with Family Room/Rec Room Possibilities - Dimensional Asphalt Shingle Roof 2013 - New Gutters & Downspouts 2022 - Newer Windows - Gray Aluminum Sided Exterior - New Fenced Rear Yard 2025 with Nice Landscaping - Open Porch - 1 Car Detached Rear Load Garage with Alley Access - Excellent S. Bexley Location - Excellent Value - Move in Ready!

903 Chelsea Avenue, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Michael D Carruthers ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
175 S Merkle Road, Bexley
$1,300,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Terri Ann Barnett
Elegant living meets relaxed sophistication in this stone & stucco Central Bexley Mid-Century Modern Garrison Colonial home. Situated on a picturesque one-third-acre lot, the property offers a serene, park-like setting with mature trees, complemented by stone walkways, patio, & a custom enclosed porch. Inside, thoughtfully curated updates along with rich hardwood floors, Marvin windows and warm neutral tones create a peaceful aesthetic. The large, updated kitchen serves as the centerpiece of the home, seamlessly connecting the inviting living spaces with French doors that open to the dining and entertaining areas. The kitchen is designed for gathering, featuring a wall of windows, plentiful cabinets, several pantries & an oversized island that anchors the space. Enjoy entertaining with a new gas stovetop, stainless steel appliances, double sinks, new fixtures, new quartz counters & backsplashes. Enjoy the casual dining area in the kitchen or entertain alfresco with easy access to the relaxing enclosed porch overlooking the yard. A 2-level family room offers a striking hearth brick fireplace, tall beam ceiling and custom designed storage & shelves. The 2nd floor owner's suite with attached study/nursery offers a peaceful retreat, while 2 additional bedrooms share an updated bathroom. The 5th bedroom is another ensuite w a new bathroom, perfect for visitors or MIL suite. Lower level offers a finished recreation room and dedicated laundry area. Completing the property is a detached two car garage. This lovely home offers a rare combination of a sensible layout, loads of updates and a beautiful setting in the heart of coveted Central Bexley. Meticulously maintained by previous owners for over 36 years! Steps from Powell Ave, close walk to main Bexley school campus, parks, Main St., Broad St., churches, synagogues, public transportation. Minutes' drive to Airport, downtown, museums, theaters, stadiums, sports fields.

175 S Merkle Road, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Terri Ann Barnett ---- RE/MAX Main Street
2805 Columbus Avenue, Bexley
$300,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Ricky Compton
Held by the same owners since 1966, this classic Cape Cod sits in one of Bexley's most sought-after pockets because of the convenient location, timeless architecture, shops, businesses, and the highly rated Bexley City Schools district. Step inside to an exceptionally spacious living room, filled with natural light and built for everything from quiet evenings to a house full of guests. The kitchen offers generous counter and cabinet space with room to gather, cook, and linger. An extremely rare footprint for a home of this era and style. A first-floor owner's suite is the standout feature, delivering the main-level convenience today's buyers look for while keeping the charm and character of a true Cape Cod. Upstairs, additional bedroom spaces offer flexibility for guests, a home office, or whatever the next chapter calls for. Major peace of mind is already handled: **brand-new roof was installed in October 2026**

2805 Columbus Avenue, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Ricky Compton ---- RE/MAX ONE
2409 Sherwood Road, Bexley
$1,250,000
4 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Sandy L Raines
Welcome home to this stately Georgian brick home in the heart of Bexley, where timeless architecture, thoughtful updates and an exceptional location come together beautifully. Filled with natural light and warmth, this special 4-bedroom home offers 4 full baths and 2 half baths, generous living spaces, abundant storage and character that makes Bexley homes so cherished. The stunning renovated kitchen is the heart of the home, beautifully designed for both everyday living and gathering with family and friends. The updated primary suite offers a peaceful retreat, while the spacious finished lower level provides wonderful flexibility for movie nights, playtime, hobbies, a home office or simply relaxing together. The third floor offers a private fourth-bedroom suite, creating a wonderful retreat for guests, teens, an office or anyone looking for a little extra space and privacy. With storage thoughtfully incorporated throughout, there is room for everything life brings. The 4-car garage is an extraordinary Bexley find, with one side heated and air conditioned, perfect for a workshop, studio, hobby space, home gym or year-round workspace. Outside, a beautiful paver patio and mature gardens create a setting made for morning coffee, summer evenings and gathering with the people you love. The location truly could not be more convenient. Just moments from Main Street's wonderful restaurants, shops and everyday amenities, with the local farmers market right around the corner. The nearby Bexley Cassingham school complex adds even more opportunities to enjoy recreation, community events and the traditions that make Bexley such a special place to call home. This is more than a beautiful house. It is the kind of home where everyday moments become memories, where neighbors become friends, gardens grow through the years, family gathers around the kitchen and life feels wonderfully connected. A truly special opportunity to make your own Bexley story.

2409 Sherwood Road, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Sandy L Raines ---- The Raines Group, Inc.
934 Ferndale Place, Bexley
$210,000
⋅ Richard Russo
Fantastic turnkey investment opportunity in the highly desirable Bexley School District! This charming all-brick duplex is fully leased and income-producing from day one, with current rents of $850 and $750 per month plus utilities. The location is hard to beat! Enjoy easy access to Schneider Park, Bexley Community Gardens, the Jewish Community Center, nearby dog park, and walking and biking trails, while still being within walking distance of the restaurants, shops, and amenities along Bexley's Main Street. Capital University is also nearby, and convenient highway access makes getting around Columbus a breeze. The property features updated living spaces, a yard, and convenient off-street parking. Its classic brick construction offers timeless curb appeal, while the combination of green space, walkability, and proximity to Bexley amenities helps support strong long-term rental appeal. With both units already occupied and tenants paying their own utilities, this is an excellent opportunity to add an established, income-producing duplex in a sought-after location to your investment portfolio!

934 Ferndale Place, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Richard Russo ---- Rich Russo Realty & Co.
920 Ferndale Place, Bexley
$224,900
⋅ Richard Russo
Fantastic investment or owner-occupant opportunity in the highly desirable Bexley School District! This charming all-brick duplex is vacant, updated, and ready for new tenants--giving the next owner the flexibility to select tenants and establish rents from day one. The location is hard to beat! Enjoy easy access to Schneider Park, Bexley Community Gardens, the Jewish Community Center, nearby dog park, and walking and biking trails, while still being within walking distance of the restaurants, shops, and amenities along Bexley's Main Street. Capital University is also nearby, and convenient highway access makes getting around Columbus a breeze. Both units offer comfortable, updated living spaces along with a yard and convenient off-street parking. The classic brick exterior provides timeless curb appeal and low-maintenance durability, while the combination of green space, walkability, and proximity to Bexley amenities adds tremendous rental appeal. Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio or live in one unit while renting the other, this turnkey duplex offers an exceptional combination of location, flexibility, and potential!

920 Ferndale Place, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Richard Russo ---- Rich Russo Realty & Co.
2191 Bryden Road, Bexley
$829,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Sheila M Straub
Handsome Center Hall Colonial with beautiful architectural detail highlighting crown moldings, original built-in cabinetry, hardwood flooring, French doors, handsome renovated kitchen with a large island, lots of cabinetry for the ideal storage needed if you are one who loves to cook! Two newly renovated bathrooms, a side porch area and a back porch area and both could potentially be screened in. Large brick garage. Furnace 2022,Water Heater 2021, EV Charger installed 2022, New Water service line 2024, New windows 2024, New plumbing stack 2025, New Front entry stoop 2026, restored original locks 2026, New Front landscaping 2023. Roof maintained by Durable Slate. This home sits on a great Central Bexley lot of 74 x 200 with ample room for expansion. Ideal location close proximity to Main Street and all the conveniences of shopping at Giant Eagle, Restaurants, The Historical Drexel Theatre, Programs at Capital University, The amazing Bexley Library, Cherbourg Bakery, New Fangled Kitchen, Giuseppe's, Kitty's, Gramercy, Ice Cream Parlors and many other choices for fun days and evenings! Be prepared to fall in love with the oozing charm and character present in every room. Easy access to Downtown, Airport, Freeways, Easton Shopping! 'A for Adorable!'

2191 Bryden Road, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : Sheila M Straub ---- Coldwell Banker Realty
24 N Merkle Road, Bexley
$749,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ William M Gingery
Incredible value with more than 3,000 square feet of living space in the Bexley City School District! Hardwood floors extend throughout the first floor, which features an updated kitchen with quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, island seating and an open connection to the light-filled family room. The spacious first-floor primary suite includes a walk-in closet, direct outdoor access, washer and dryer hookups, and an updated bathroom with dual sinks, a soaking tub and spa-style shower. Four additional spacious bedrooms are located on the second floor. Additional highlights include a large all-weather breezeway with a mini-split system connecting the home to the two-car garage, a large basement, whole-house generator and alarm system. Outside, enjoy a private side deck, gated driveway and low-maintenance turf backyard enclosed by a six-foot privacy fence. The main roof is less than 10 years old, the flat roof was replaced in July 2026 and the front siding was replaced in 2019. Offering generous living spaces, thoughtful updates and exceptional privacy, this Bexley home is ready for its next owner!

24 N Merkle Road, Bexley

Listing Courtesy of : William M Gingery ---- Rich Russo Realty & Co.
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!